When an individual is made bankrupt, their trustee in bankruptcy will ordinarily become entitled to the bankrupt's beneficial interest in any property they own.
However, disputes can arise over the extent of that interest, particularly where the property is jointly owned with a spouse, partner or family member, or where the legal ownership does not reflect the parties' underlying financial arrangements.
A trustee may contend that the bankrupt owned a substantial beneficial interest in a property, while another person maintains that the bankrupt's interest was much smaller, or that the bankrupt had no beneficial interest at all.
These disputes can have serious consequences. The outcome may determine whether the trustee can seek to realise an interest in the family home, the value of that interest and whether a proposed sale can be resisted.
At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we advise on disputes involving trustees in bankruptcy, property ownership and the realisation of assets. We can investigate the underlying ownership arrangements, assess the evidence and represent clients in negotiations and court proceedings where necessary.
What is the difference between legal ownership and beneficial ownership?
English property law distinguishes between legal ownership and beneficial ownership.
Legal ownership refers to the persons registered as proprietors of the property at HM Land Registry. Beneficial ownership concerns who is entitled to the economic value of the property, including the proceeds when it is sold.
The two do not always correspond.
For example, a property may be registered in the joint names of a married couple, but there may be an argument that their beneficial interests are unequal.
Alternatively, a property may be registered in one person's name, while another person claims a beneficial interest arising from their financial contributions or an agreement concerning ownership.
The distinction is particularly important in bankruptcy because the trustee generally acquires the bankrupt's beneficial interest, rather than the beneficial interests belonging to other people.
The trustee cannot simply treat the whole value of a jointly owned property as an asset of the bankruptcy estate.
What happens to jointly owned property when one owner becomes bankrupt?
Where a property is jointly owned and one of the owners becomes bankrupt, the bankrupt's beneficial interest will ordinarily vest in the trustee in bankruptcy.
The non-bankrupt co-owner retains their own beneficial interest.
The bankruptcy will also generally sever any beneficial joint tenancy, so that the relevant interests are held as tenants in common.
The trustee may seek to agree the value of the bankrupt's interest with the non-bankrupt co-owner or another purchaser.
If an agreement cannot be reached, the trustee may seek a court determination of the beneficial ownership position and, where appropriate, an order for possession and sale.
However, the proportion of the property belonging to the bankrupt may be disputed.
Establishing the correct beneficial ownership position can therefore be a crucial first step.
Is the bankrupt automatically entitled to half the equity in a jointly owned property?
No. Although equal beneficial ownership is often the starting point where a family home is purchased in joint names, it is not an absolute rule.
The leading authorities include Stack v Dowden [2007] UKHL 17 and Jones v Kernott [2011] UKSC 53.
These cases establish that, in the domestic context, joint legal ownership ordinarily gives rise to a presumption of joint beneficial ownership in equal shares.
However, that presumption may be rebutted by evidence that the parties intended their beneficial interests to be different.
The court may consider the parties' whole course of conduct in relation to the property.
Relevant circumstances may include their discussions and agreements, the arrangements made when the property was purchased, how the mortgage and household finances were dealt with, and whether their intentions changed over time.
The fact that one person contributed more towards the purchase price or mortgage does not automatically mean that they own a correspondingly larger beneficial share.
Each case requires careful consideration of the evidence and the applicable legal principles.
What if the property is registered in only one person's name?
Where a property is registered in one person's sole name, the starting point is generally that the registered proprietor is also its sole beneficial owner.
However, another person may be able to establish a beneficial interest through a constructive trust, resulting trust or another legally recognised arrangement.
For example, a spouse or partner may claim that there was a common intention that they would share ownership of the property and that they acted to their detriment in reliance on that understanding.
If the claim is established, the beneficial ownership position may differ from the Land Registry title.
This can be particularly important where the bankrupt is the sole registered proprietor but a non-bankrupt spouse or family member claims a share.
It can also arise where the property is registered in the name of a non-bankrupt person but the trustee alleges that the bankrupt retained an undisclosed beneficial interest.
In either situation, the legal title is important evidence but may not provide the complete answer.
How can a beneficial interest arise under a constructive trust?
A common intention constructive trust may arise where the parties shared an intention that a person would have a beneficial interest in the property and that person acted to their detriment in reliance on that intention.
The common intention may be expressed in discussions or agreements, or in appropriate circumstances inferred from conduct.
The court will examine the evidence to determine whether the necessary legal requirements have been established.
Relevant matters may include contributions towards the purchase price or mortgage, discussions about ownership, and the arrangements made between the parties.
However, not every contribution to household expenses or improvement of a property establishes a beneficial interest.
It is necessary to consider the nature of the contribution, the parties' intentions and whether the alleged conduct supports the particular claim being advanced.
The principles applicable to sole-name cases may differ from those governing properties purchased in joint names.
What is a resulting trust?
A resulting trust may arise in certain circumstances where one person contributes towards the purchase price of a property registered in another person's name.
In some cases, the beneficial ownership may reflect the parties' respective contributions to the acquisition.
However, resulting trust principles do not automatically determine ownership in every domestic property dispute.
In disputes concerning the family home, the courts frequently apply the principles governing common intention constructive trusts.
The appropriate legal analysis will depend on the nature of the property, the relationship between the parties, the transaction and the evidence.
A claim should therefore not be based solely on a mathematical comparison of financial contributions without considering the wider legal position.
What if there is a declaration of trust?
A properly executed declaration of trust can be highly significant.
Where the parties have expressly declared their beneficial interests, the declaration will generally determine the ownership position, subject to any legally recognised grounds for challenging its validity or effect.
The court will not ordinarily disregard an effective declaration merely because one party later considers the agreed shares unfair.
The importance of express declarations of trust was emphasised in Goodman v Gallant [1986] Fam 106.
Accordingly, one of the first steps in any beneficial ownership dispute should be to establish whether a declaration of trust exists and, if so, examine its wording.
It may also be necessary to consider whether there have been subsequent legally effective changes to the parties' interests.
Can a trustee in bankruptcy challenge an alleged beneficial interest?
Yes.
A trustee may investigate whether a claimed beneficial interest is genuine and legally enforceable.
This may arise where a spouse, partner or family member asserts that the bankrupt owned a smaller share of the property than the legal title or other evidence initially suggests.
The trustee may request supporting documents and explanations concerning the ownership arrangements.
The trustee may also examine the timing of any alleged agreement or transfer, particularly where it occurred shortly before bankruptcy.
Depending on the circumstances, the trustee may consider whether a transaction is vulnerable to challenge under the Insolvency Act 1986, including the provisions concerning transactions at an undervalue or transactions intended to prejudice creditors.
An existing beneficial interest should be distinguished from an interest purportedly transferred by the bankrupt before bankruptcy.
The legal issues can be materially different.
What if the bankrupt transferred their interest before bankruptcy?
A transfer of property or a beneficial interest before bankruptcy does not necessarily prevent the trustee from challenging the transaction.
For example, section 339 of the Insolvency Act 1986 provides powers concerning certain transactions at an undervalue.
Section 423 contains provisions addressing transactions entered into for the purpose of putting assets beyond the reach of creditors or otherwise prejudicing their interests.
Different statutory requirements, time limits and remedies apply.
The trustee may seek to establish that a purported transfer should be set aside or that the bankruptcy estate remains entitled to an interest in the property.
However, not every transfer made before bankruptcy is automatically invalid.
It is necessary to examine when the transaction took place, what consideration was provided, the financial circumstances of the bankrupt and the relevant statutory provisions.
Can a spouse or family member dispute the trustee's claimed share?
Yes.
A spouse, partner or family member may have grounds to challenge the trustee's assessment of the bankrupt's beneficial interest.
For example, there may be evidence of an express agreement that the parties would hold the property in unequal shares.
Alternatively, the circumstances may support a claim that a person who is not registered as a proprietor nevertheless has a beneficial interest.
The dispute may be resolved through negotiations supported by appropriate documentary evidence.
Where agreement cannot be reached, a court determination may be necessary.
The important point is that a trustee's initial assessment of the bankrupt's beneficial interest is not necessarily conclusive.
The ownership position must be determined in accordance with the law and the available evidence.
What evidence is needed to establish beneficial ownership?
Beneficial ownership disputes are often highly fact-sensitive.
The strength of a claim may depend on documents created many years before the bankruptcy.
Relevant evidence may include:
The Land Registry title and transfer documents.
Any declaration of trust or written ownership agreement.
Solicitors' correspondence from the original purchase.
Mortgage applications and mortgage statements.
Bank statements showing contributions towards the purchase price or mortgage.
Evidence of the source of any deposit.
Correspondence between the parties concerning ownership.
Documents relating to refinancing or later changes in ownership arrangements.
Evidence of financial arrangements and relevant conduct.
Witness statements explaining the parties' intentions and the history of the property.
Contemporaneous documents can be particularly important where the parties now give conflicting accounts of what was agreed.
A careful review of the evidence may reveal that the trustee's assumed ownership proportions are open to challenge.
Equally, the evidence may demonstrate that a proposed beneficial ownership claim is unlikely to succeed.
It is important to assess both possibilities realistically.
What happens if the trustee and co-owner cannot agree?
Where the parties cannot agree on the beneficial ownership position, the dispute may have to be determined by the court.
Depending on the circumstances, proceedings may involve an application for declarations concerning the parties' respective beneficial interests.
The court may consider the legal title, any express trust documentation, financial contributions, the parties' intentions and the other relevant evidence.
If the trustee is also seeking possession and sale, the ownership dispute may need to be resolved as part of, or alongside, those proceedings.
The outcome can have a significant effect on the value of the trustee's interest and the amount potentially available for creditors.
However, establishing that the bankrupt owned a smaller share does not necessarily prevent the trustee from seeking to realise that share.
The question of beneficial ownership is distinct from the court's powers concerning possession and sale.
Can a beneficial ownership dispute prevent the sale of the family home?
Potentially, although not necessarily.
If the trustee cannot establish that the bankrupt had the beneficial interest claimed, the trustee's entitlement to seek relief based on that interest may be affected.
For example, a finding that the bankrupt had no beneficial interest in the property may fundamentally undermine the trustee's claim to realise it.
Where the bankrupt owned a smaller interest than alleged, that may affect the economic justification for pursuing a sale or the terms on which the dispute can be settled.
However, even a relatively small beneficial interest may be capable of realisation.
Where the trustee establishes an interest and seeks an order for possession and sale, the court must apply the relevant statutory provisions, including section 335A of the Insolvency Act 1986 where applicable.
The existence of a beneficial ownership dispute should therefore be considered alongside the wider legal and practical options.
Can the trustee's beneficial interest be purchased instead?
Yes.
Where the trustee has a beneficial interest in a property, it may be possible for a spouse, family member or another third party to purchase that interest.
This can provide an alternative to contested proceedings and a forced sale.
The purchase price will depend on a number of factors, including the value of the property, the outstanding mortgage and other secured liabilities, the bankrupt's beneficial ownership and the particular circumstances of the bankruptcy.
Importantly, the bankrupt's proportionate share of the equity does not necessarily represent the amount that must be paid to acquire the trustee's interest.
At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we have considerable experience negotiating with trustees in bankruptcy and seeking to agree purchases on favourable terms for our clients.
A negotiated purchase can offer advantages to both the purchaser and the bankruptcy estate, and there may be opportunities to agree a price below the apparent value of the bankrupt's beneficial interest.
Every case will depend on its individual circumstances, and a trustee is not obliged to accept a particular offer.
Our objective is to secure the purchase of the trustee's interest on the most favourable terms reasonably achievable, allowing the family home to be retained wherever possible.
What are the risks of pursuing a beneficial ownership dispute?
Litigation concerning beneficial ownership can be expensive and uncertain.
The court may have to consider evidence spanning many years, including financial records, witness accounts and disputed agreements.
Where the documentary evidence is incomplete, the outcome may depend heavily on the court's assessment of the parties' credibility and the inferences properly drawn from their conduct.
If a claim is unsuccessful, there may be an adverse costs order.
It is therefore important to obtain an early assessment of the merits before committing to substantial proceedings.
In appropriate cases, a negotiated settlement may offer a more proportionate outcome than litigation.
Should specialist counsel be instructed?
Beneficial ownership disputes can involve complex questions of property, trust and insolvency law.
Where substantial interests are at stake or contested proceedings are contemplated, it will often be advisable to obtain specialist counsel's opinion on the merits of the proposed claim or defence.
At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we work closely with experienced barristers who specialise in insolvency and related property disputes.
Where appropriate, we can arrange for counsel to advise on the ownership issues, assess the prospects of success and represent clients in court proceedings.
This allows us to provide coordinated advice on both the legal dispute and the practical options for resolving it.
How much does it cost to resolve a beneficial ownership dispute?
The legal costs will depend on the complexity of the ownership arrangements, the available evidence and whether the matter can be resolved without contested proceedings.
In some cases, it may be possible to assess the position from the Land Registry documents, declarations of trust and relevant financial records, followed by negotiations with the trustee.
Other matters may require substantial investigation, witness evidence, specialist counsel's advice and court proceedings.
We will provide an estimate of our fees after reviewing the circumstances and identifying the work likely to be required.
Where counsel or other experts are needed, their fees will be discussed separately.
We will also explain the potential risks of litigation, including the possibility of an adverse costs order.
How Bowman Abraham Solicitors can assist
We advise clients involved in disputes concerning beneficial ownership of property and trustees in bankruptcy.
Our work includes:
Investigating the beneficial ownership of jointly owned and solely owned properties.
Advising spouses, partners and family members on their property interests.
Reviewing declarations of trust and historic ownership arrangements.
Assessing claims based on constructive and resulting trusts.
Challenging the extent of a trustee's claimed beneficial interest.
Reviewing evidence concerning financial contributions and ownership intentions.
Negotiating with trustees in bankruptcy.
Advising on the purchase of a trustee's beneficial interest.
Defending applications for possession and sale where appropriate.
Instructing specialist counsel and arranging representation in court proceedings.
We recognise that disputes concerning the family home can have consequences extending well beyond the financial value of the property.
Our approach is to examine the underlying legal position carefully and identify a practical resolution wherever possible.
Speak to a solicitor about a beneficial ownership dispute
If a trustee in bankruptcy is claiming an interest in your home, or you believe that the trustee has incorrectly assessed the bankrupt's share of a property, it is important to obtain legal advice before accepting the trustee's position.
The outcome may depend on historic ownership arrangements, documents and evidence which should be examined at an early stage.
Bowman Abraham Solicitors can advise on the ownership dispute, the trustee's entitlement and the options available to protect your interests.
Michael Abraham — Partner
michael.abraham@bowman-abraham.co.uk
Bowman Abraham Solicitors
This article provides general information about the law of England and Wales and does not constitute legal advice on individual circumstances.
