← Personal Bankruptcy & Insolvency

Defending an Application for Possession and Sale by a Trustee in Bankruptcy

If a trustee in bankruptcy has commenced proceedings seeking possession and sale of your family home, you may be concerned about the prospect of losing your property.

Although a trustee has significant powers to realise a bankrupt's interest in property for the benefit of creditors, an application for possession and sale does not necessarily mean that the property will have to be sold.

Depending on the circumstances, there may be grounds to challenge the application, dispute the extent of the trustee's beneficial interest, seek an adjournment or negotiate an arrangement which allows the family to remain in the home.

At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we advise bankrupt individuals, spouses, co-owners and family members facing applications for possession and sale by trustees in bankruptcy.

We have experience dealing with disputes concerning beneficial ownership, the valuation of property interests and negotiations for the purchase of a trustee's beneficial interest.

Our objective is to identify the most effective legal and practical means of protecting the family home.

Why can a trustee in bankruptcy apply to sell the family home?

When an individual is made bankrupt, their assets generally vest in the trustee in bankruptcy, subject to certain statutory exceptions.

These assets ordinarily include the bankrupt's beneficial interest in their home.

The trustee's responsibility is to realise the assets of the bankruptcy estate and distribute the proceeds in accordance with the statutory insolvency regime.

Where the bankrupt has an interest in a property, the trustee may seek to realise that interest by agreement.

However, if an agreement cannot be reached, the trustee may apply to the court for possession and sale.

The legal position will depend on whether the property is solely owned by the bankrupt, jointly owned with a spouse or another person, or subject to a dispute concerning beneficial ownership.

Importantly, the trustee does not automatically acquire the beneficial interest belonging to a non-bankrupt spouse or other co-owner.

What powers does the trustee have to obtain possession and sale?

The principal statutory provisions are contained in the Insolvency Act 1986.

Section 335A of the Insolvency Act 1986

Section 335A deals with certain applications concerning a home in which a bankrupt has an interest, including applications relating to property held on trust.

It is particularly relevant where the property is jointly owned and the trustee seeks an order for sale.

The court must consider a number of factors when determining the application, including:

  • The interests of the bankrupt's creditors.

  • The conduct of the spouse or civil partner, insofar as it contributed to the bankruptcy.

  • The needs and financial resources of the spouse or civil partner.

  • The needs of any children.

  • All the circumstances of the case, other than the needs of the bankrupt.

However, the weight given to these factors changes significantly once the relevant one-year period has elapsed.

Section 336 of the Insolvency Act 1986

Section 336 is relevant where the bankrupt's estate includes a dwelling-house which was the sole or principal residence of the bankrupt, their spouse or civil partner, or former spouse or civil partner.

It contains provisions relating to the rights of occupation of such a property.

Applications involving solely owned property can therefore raise different issues from those concerning a jointly owned family home.

It is important to identify the correct statutory basis for the trustee's application and the nature of the property interest involved.

What is the one-year rule?

One of the most important aspects of defending an application for sale is the statutory presumption which applies after one year.

Under section 335A(3) of the Insolvency Act 1986, where the application is made more than one year after the bankruptcy estate first vested in the trustee, the court must generally assume that the interests of creditors outweigh all other considerations unless the circumstances of the case are exceptional.

This is a significant hurdle for anyone seeking to prevent the sale of the family home.

Before the expiry of the relevant period, the court considers the statutory factors without that particular presumption.

Afterwards, the interests of creditors will ordinarily prevail unless exceptional circumstances can be established.

The fact that the property is a family home, or that its sale will cause distress and disruption, will not usually be sufficient by itself.

Does the one-year rule mean the trustee automatically gets an order for sale?

No.

The statutory presumption is important, but it does not mean that the court must grant every application made by a trustee.

The court must still consider the applicable legal requirements, the evidence and the circumstances of the case.

There may be disputes about the trustee's entitlement to the property, the beneficial ownership position or whether exceptional circumstances exist.

It may also be appropriate for the court to consider the timing of any possession order or whether a short adjournment would enable a realistic alternative to sale to be completed.

However, a person defending proceedings should not underestimate the strength of the trustee's position once the statutory presumption applies.

What amounts to exceptional circumstances?

There is no exhaustive definition of exceptional circumstances.

The courts have consistently recognised that the ordinary consequences of bankruptcy, including financial hardship, disruption to family life and the need to find alternative accommodation, will not normally be exceptional.

The circumstances must be sufficiently unusual to justify departing from the statutory presumption in favour of creditors.

Relevant matters may include particularly serious medical conditions, exceptional care requirements or other circumstances going substantially beyond the ordinary hardship associated with losing a family home.

Each case must be considered on its own facts.

What does the case law say about exceptional circumstances?

The courts have consistently adopted a restrictive approach to the meaning of exceptional circumstances under section 335A of the Insolvency Act 1986.

In Re Citro (Domenico) [1991] Ch 142, the Court of Appeal established that the ordinary hardship associated with the sale of a family home, including difficulties obtaining alternative accommodation and disruption to children's schooling, will not generally constitute exceptional circumstances.

However, the courts have recognised that particularly serious medical conditions, disabilities and unusual personal circumstances may justify a different approach.

In Claughton v Charalambous [1998] BPIR 558, exceptional circumstances involving the non-bankrupt spouse's health justified postponement of a sale.

In Grant v Baker [2016] EWHC 1782 (Ch), the High Court accepted that the circumstances of an adult daughter with significant disabilities were exceptional. Nevertheless, the court held that an indefinite postponement was inappropriate and limited the period of postponement.

More recently, in Reid-Roberts v Mei-Lin [2026] EWHC 49 (Ch), the High Court reaffirmed that even where exceptional circumstances exist, the court must still balance the competing interests and determine an appropriate period before the property is sold.

These decisions establish that exceptional circumstances can justify resisting or postponing a sale, but do not necessarily provide a permanent defence to the trustee's application.

The outcome will depend on the particular facts, the quality of the supporting evidence and the court's assessment of the competing interests.

Should specialist insolvency counsel be instructed?

Given the complexity of the law and the restrictive approach adopted by the courts, it will usually be advisable to obtain an opinion from specialist insolvency counsel before pursuing a contested challenge to an application for possession and sale.

This is particularly important where the proposed defence relies on exceptional circumstances under section 335A of the Insolvency Act 1986.

At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we work closely with experienced barristers who specialise in insolvency law and can provide expert advice and representation throughout the proceedings.

Where appropriate, we will arrange for specialist counsel to advise on the merits of the proposed defence and the prospects of successfully resisting or postponing a sale. Counsel can also represent clients at court hearings, including contested final hearings.

This collaborative approach enables us to provide clients with a realistic assessment of their position and a coordinated strategy for dealing with the proceedings.

Where the prospects of successfully defending the application are limited, we will also explore whether a negotiated purchase of the trustee's beneficial interest or another practical resolution may offer a more favourable outcome.

Can the presence of children prevent the sale of the family home?

The needs of children are expressly relevant under section 335A.

The court may consider their ages, educational needs, living arrangements and any particular vulnerabilities.

However, the presence of children in the property does not, by itself, establish exceptional circumstances.

Where the statutory presumption applies, the court will generally regard the ordinary disruption associated with moving home as an expected consequence of bankruptcy.

The position may be different where there are unusual circumstances, such as particularly serious disabilities or exceptional care requirements.

In such cases, detailed supporting evidence may be necessary.

It may also be possible to seek a postponement of possession to allow suitable alternative arrangements to be made, even where the court is not persuaded that a sale should be prevented altogether.

What if a spouse or family member has serious medical needs?

Serious medical circumstances can be relevant to an application for possession and sale.

However, it is important to distinguish between the existence of a medical condition and the consequences that a forced move would have for the person concerned.

For example, a person may have significant medical needs which require specialist accommodation, adaptations or a particular care arrangement.

The court may need to consider whether suitable alternative accommodation is realistically available and the likely consequences of requiring the person to leave the property.

Medical evidence should address these issues directly.

Relevant evidence may include:

  • Reports from treating consultants or other medical professionals.

  • Details of the person's condition and care requirements.

  • Evidence of adaptations to the property.

  • Information about suitable alternative accommodation.

  • Evidence concerning the likely consequences of relocation.

The stronger the evidence concerning the exceptional impact of a sale, the better the court will be placed to consider whether the statutory presumption should be displaced or whether some postponement is appropriate.

Can the trustee's beneficial interest be challenged?

Yes.

In some cases, the most effective defence is not based on exceptional circumstances but on a dispute concerning the extent of the bankrupt's beneficial interest in the property.

The trustee can generally realise only the interest which belonged to the bankrupt.

Where a property is jointly owned, the trustee does not automatically become entitled to the non-bankrupt co-owner's share.

For example, a spouse may contend that the bankrupt owned a smaller beneficial interest than the trustee alleges.

Alternatively, a family member may claim an independent beneficial interest arising from an express trust or other legally recognised arrangement.

The outcome will depend on the ownership documents, the applicable legal principles and the available evidence.

What evidence may be relevant to beneficial ownership?

Depending on the circumstances, relevant documents may include:

  • The Land Registry title.

  • Any declaration of trust.

  • Documents relating to the original purchase.

  • Mortgage documentation.

  • Evidence of relevant financial contributions.

  • Correspondence or agreements concerning ownership.

  • Evidence of the parties' intentions and arrangements.

The fact that one person made larger financial contributions does not automatically establish that they own a correspondingly larger share, particularly in a jointly owned family home.

A detailed assessment of the legal and factual position may therefore be required.

Where there is a substantial dispute concerning beneficial ownership, it may be necessary for the court to determine the parties' respective interests before the trustee's entitlement can be properly assessed.

What if the trustee has overvalued the property?

The value of the property and the bankrupt's beneficial interest may be central to the proceedings.

A trustee may rely on a valuation which is disputed by the bankrupt or the non-bankrupt co-owner.

For example, the valuation may not adequately reflect the property's condition, necessary repairs or other factors affecting its market value.

It may be appropriate to obtain an independent valuation from a suitably qualified surveyor.

The outstanding mortgage and any other secured liabilities must also be considered.

A disagreement about valuation does not necessarily provide a complete defence to an application for sale. However, it may materially affect the trustee's assessment of the interest and the prospects of reaching a negotiated settlement.

What if there is little or no equity in the property?

Where a property is in negative equity or has very limited equity, there may be little immediate financial benefit to the bankruptcy estate from a sale.

For example, the proceeds may be substantially absorbed by the mortgage, other secured liabilities and the expenses of realisation.

In such circumstances, it may be appropriate to question whether the proposed sale would produce a meaningful recovery for creditors.

However, negative equity does not automatically prevent the trustee from pursuing the property.

The trustee may take account of the prospect of future increases in value, reductions in secured borrowing and the applicable statutory time limits.

The precise position will depend on the evidence and the circumstances of the bankruptcy.

Can the three-year rule prevent the trustee from selling the property?

Potentially, yes.

Section 283A of the Insolvency Act 1986 contains provisions limiting the period during which a trustee may retain an interest in certain properties which qualify as the bankrupt's family home.

Broadly, the trustee must take one of the prescribed statutory steps within the applicable three-year period.

If the trustee fails to do so, the interest will generally revest in the bankrupt.

However, the three-year rule is subject to important qualifications and exceptions.

For example, the trustee may preserve the interest by making a qualifying application for possession or sale within the relevant period.

The trustee does not necessarily have to complete the sale before the period expires.

Where proceedings have been commenced close to or after the expiry of the three-year period, it is important to examine the dates carefully.

The relevant documents may include the bankruptcy order, any appointment of a trustee, court applications and orders, and correspondence concerning the property.

If the interest has already revested in the bankrupt, that may have a fundamental effect on the trustee's entitlement to pursue the property.

Can an application for possession and sale be adjourned?

Yes.

The court has discretion to adjourn proceedings where appropriate.

An adjournment may be sought where there is a genuine prospect of resolving the dispute or completing an arrangement which would avoid the need for a forced sale.

For example, a spouse or family member may be in the process of obtaining finance to purchase the trustee's beneficial interest.

Alternatively, further evidence may be required to determine the parties' respective beneficial interests.

However, the court will not necessarily grant an adjournment simply because the occupants would prefer additional time.

A request for an adjournment should ordinarily be supported by evidence demonstrating why further time is needed and what is realistically expected to be achieved.

What if finance is being arranged?

Where a proposed purchase depends on mortgage finance or specialist lending, it may be helpful to provide evidence of the funding arrangements.

This could include a mortgage offer, correspondence from a lender or evidence that the proposed transaction is progressing towards completion.

The court will be concerned with whether there is a realistic prospect of completion within a reasonable period.

An unsupported assertion that finance may become available is unlikely to carry the same weight as a properly evidenced proposal.

Can the trustee's interest be purchased after proceedings have commenced?

Yes.

Even where the trustee has commenced proceedings for possession and sale, it may still be possible to negotiate the purchase of the trustee's beneficial interest.

This can provide an alternative to selling the property on the open market.

A spouse, family member or other third party may be able to purchase the interest, allowing the family to remain in the home.

Importantly, the price payable for the trustee's interest does not necessarily have to be identical to the bankrupt's mathematical share of the property's equity.

At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we have considerable experience negotiating with trustees in bankruptcy and seeking to agree purchases on favourable terms for our clients.

A negotiated purchase may provide advantages to both the purchaser and the bankruptcy estate, and there may be scope to agree a price below the apparent value of the bankrupt's beneficial interest.

The outcome will depend on the circumstances, and a trustee is not obliged to accept a particular offer.

However, negotiations can remain worthwhile even after court proceedings have begun.

Is it better to negotiate before the hearing?

Generally, yes.

Once proceedings have been commenced, the trustee may incur further legal expenses which can complicate negotiations.

There is also the risk that the court will make an order for possession and sale before an agreement has been reached.

Early negotiations may therefore provide a greater opportunity to resolve the matter without the costs and uncertainty of a contested hearing.

However, the existence of ongoing negotiations does not automatically suspend the court proceedings.

Unless the proceedings are formally adjourned, stayed or otherwise dealt with by the court, the parties must continue to comply with applicable deadlines and directions.

Can the court postpone an order for possession?

In appropriate circumstances, yes.

Even where the court concludes that the property should ultimately be sold, it may be possible to seek an order postponing the date for possession.

This may allow time for alternative accommodation to be arranged, for a proposed purchase to be completed or for particular personal circumstances to be addressed.

The court will consider the evidence and the interests of the parties.

A postponement should not be confused with a permanent refusal of an order for sale.

It may provide valuable time, but it does not necessarily remove the trustee's entitlement to realise the property.

What should you do if you receive an application for possession and sale?

It is important to act promptly.

The first step is to review the application, the supporting evidence and any court directions.

The defendant should establish the legal basis of the trustee's claim and identify whether there are grounds to dispute the trustee's entitlement, the extent of the beneficial interest or the relief sought.

Consideration should also be given to whether a negotiated purchase or other practical arrangement is achievable.

Where proceedings are to be defended, appropriate evidence should be prepared and filed in accordance with the applicable procedural requirements.

What documents should be obtained?

Depending on the circumstances, relevant documents may include:

  • The bankruptcy order and details of the trustee's appointment.

  • The application for possession and sale and supporting witness statements.

  • The Land Registry title and any declaration of trust.

  • Mortgage statements and details of other secured liabilities.

  • Property valuations.

  • Evidence supporting any dispute concerning beneficial ownership.

  • Medical or other evidence of exceptional circumstances.

  • Correspondence with the trustee.

  • Evidence of any proposed funding or purchase arrangements.

The appropriate response will depend on the particular issues raised by the application.

It is important not to assume that the trustee's valuation, assessment of beneficial ownership or entitlement to relief is necessarily correct.

What happens at the court hearing?

At the hearing, the trustee will seek to establish the entitlement to possession and sale.

The court will consider the applicable statutory provisions and the evidence filed by the parties.

The defendant may seek to challenge the application, establish exceptional circumstances, dispute the trustee's beneficial interest or request an adjournment or postponement.

Depending on the circumstances, the court may:

  • Make an order for possession and sale.

  • Refuse or dismiss the application.

  • Adjourn the proceedings.

  • Determine or give directions for determining disputed beneficial interests.

  • Postpone possession or make other appropriate directions.

  • Make an order concerning the costs of the proceedings.

The precise outcome will depend on the legal issues, the evidence and the court's assessment of the circumstances.

What are the risks of defending possession and sale proceedings?

An application for possession and sale can involve significant financial and personal consequences.

If the trustee succeeds, the property may ultimately have to be sold.

The court may also make an order requiring an unsuccessful party to pay some or all of the other party's legal costs.

Where a dispute concerning beneficial ownership or exceptional circumstances is pursued without adequate evidence, there may be a risk of incurring substantial costs without achieving the desired outcome.

It is therefore important to assess the merits of defending the application at an early stage.

In some cases, there may be strong grounds to contest the trustee's entitlement or the extent of the beneficial interest.

In others, a negotiated purchase or agreement concerning the timing of possession may offer a more realistic and cost-effective solution.

Our approach is to consider both the legal merits and the practical alternatives before recommending a course of action.

How much does it cost to defend an application for possession and sale?

The legal costs will depend on the nature of the dispute, the complexity of the evidence and whether the proceedings can be resolved by agreement.

For example, an application involving a straightforward request for a short adjournment may require substantially less work than a contested dispute concerning beneficial ownership or exceptional circumstances.

The work may include:

  • Reviewing the application and supporting evidence.

  • Advising on the legal merits and available defences.

  • Obtaining and considering relevant documents.

  • Preparing witness statements and other evidence.

  • Negotiating with the trustee and their solicitors.

  • Preparing for court hearings.

  • Instructing counsel where appropriate.

  • Advising on settlement and the purchase of the trustee's interest.

We will provide an estimate after reviewing the application and identifying the issues in dispute.

In contested cases, we will ordinarily recommend obtaining an early written opinion from specialist insolvency counsel on the merits and prospects of the proposed defence. Counsel's fees will be discussed and agreed with the client before instructions are given.

Counsel's fees, court fees and other disbursements will be explained separately where applicable.

Where proceedings involve multiple hearings, substantial evidence or disputed beneficial ownership, additional costs may arise.

We will also advise on the potential exposure to the trustee's legal costs.

How Bowman Abraham Solicitors can assist

We advise and represent individuals and families facing applications for possession and sale by trustees in bankruptcy.

Our services include:

  • Reviewing and defending applications for possession and sale.

  • Advising on sections 335A and 336 of the Insolvency Act 1986.

  • Assessing whether exceptional circumstances may justify resisting or postponing a sale.

  • Preparing evidence concerning medical conditions and family circumstances.

  • Challenging disputed beneficial ownership claims.

  • Advising spouses and other co-owners on their property rights.

  • Challenging property valuations and assessing available equity.

  • Considering whether the trustee has complied with the three-year rule.

  • Negotiating the purchase of the trustee's beneficial interest.

  • Seeking adjournments and postponements where appropriate.

  • Preparing witness statements and evidence for court.

  • Arranging representation at contested hearings.

  • Negotiating settlements designed to avoid a forced sale.

We work closely with specialist insolvency barristers, enabling us to arrange expert advice and representation at all stages of contested proceedings.

We recognise that these proceedings can place considerable pressure on families, particularly where the property has been their home for many years.

Our objective is to identify a legally sustainable and commercially sensible solution, whether through defending the application, negotiating with the trustee or arranging the purchase of the beneficial interest.

Speak to a solicitor

If you have received an application for possession and sale from a trustee in bankruptcy, it is important to obtain advice as soon as possible.

There may be grounds to challenge the application, dispute the trustee's claimed interest or negotiate an arrangement which avoids the sale of the family home.

Early advice can also help ensure that court deadlines are met and that the available options are properly considered before a possession order is made.

Michael Abraham — Partner

07813 493391

michael.abraham@bowman-abraham.co.uk

Bowman Abraham Solicitors

020 3732 0424

This article provides general information about the law of England and Wales and does not constitute legal advice on individual circumstances.