← Corporate Insolvency & Winding-Up

Can a Director Be Personally Liable for Company Debts?

One of the greatest concerns for company directors facing insolvency is whether they can be held personally responsible for the company's debts.

The general rule is that a limited company is a separate legal entity from its directors and shareholders. This means that directors are not ordinarily personally liable for debts incurred by the company.

If a company becomes insolvent and is unable to pay its creditors, those debts do not automatically become the personal responsibility of its directors.

However, there are important exceptions.

A director may face personal liability where they have given a personal guarantee, breached their duties to the company, engaged in wrongful or fraudulent trading, received company funds which must be repaid, or become involved in transactions that can be challenged following insolvency.

Liquidators also have powers to investigate the company's financial affairs and pursue claims against directors where there are proper grounds for doing so.

Importantly, the fact that a company has failed does not, by itself, establish wrongdoing by its directors.

At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we advise directors facing claims arising from company insolvency, including personal guarantees, directors' loan accounts, allegations of breach of duty and claims brought by liquidators.

Are directors personally responsible for the debts of a limited company?

Generally, no.

A limited company has its own legal personality and is responsible for its own contractual and financial obligations.

Where a company enters into a contract, borrows money or purchases goods on credit, the liability will ordinarily be that of the company rather than its directors.

For example, where a company owes money to a supplier under a commercial contract, the supplier cannot ordinarily recover that debt from the directors personally simply because the company has insufficient assets to pay.

Similarly, the fact that a director owns all the shares in a company does not mean that the company's debts become the director's personal liabilities.

Limited liability is a fundamental feature of company law.

However, it does not protect directors against liabilities they have personally undertaken or liabilities arising from their own conduct.

It is therefore important to distinguish between an ordinary unpaid company debt and a separate legal basis for making a director personally liable.

In what circumstances can a director become personally liable?

Personal liability may arise in several situations.

These include:

  • The director has signed a personal guarantee.

  • The director owes money to the company under an overdrawn director's loan account.

  • The director has breached statutory or fiduciary duties owed to the company.

  • The director is found liable for wrongful trading.

  • The director has been involved in fraudulent trading.

  • The director has misapplied company money or assets.

  • The director has received payments or benefits which can be challenged following insolvency.

  • The director has incurred a separate personal liability under a particular statutory provision.

These are different causes of action, each with its own legal requirements.

A creditor or liquidator cannot simply allege that a director behaved irresponsibly and thereby establish personal liability.

The claimant must identify a recognised legal basis for the claim and prove the necessary facts.

Can a director be personally liable under a personal guarantee?

Yes.

Personal guarantees are one of the most common reasons directors become personally responsible for company debts.

Banks, commercial landlords, finance companies and suppliers frequently require directors to guarantee the obligations of a limited company.

Where a valid personal guarantee has been given, the creditor may be entitled to pursue the director personally if the company fails to meet its obligations.

This may occur even where the company has entered liquidation.

For example, a director may have guaranteed a business loan, commercial lease or trade credit account.

The creditor's rights will depend upon the wording and enforceability of the guarantee.

Can a director challenge a personal guarantee?

Potentially, yes.

The fact that a creditor produces a document described as a personal guarantee does not necessarily mean that every amount claimed is recoverable.

Issues may arise concerning:

  • Whether the director actually entered into a binding personal guarantee.

  • Whether the guarantee was properly executed.

  • The scope of the obligations covered.

  • Whether the guarantee is limited to a particular amount.

  • Whether interest and additional charges are recoverable.

  • Whether the guarantee has been discharged or released.

  • Whether subsequent changes to the underlying obligations affect liability.

  • Whether the creditor has complied with any contractual requirements for making a demand.

  • Whether there are grounds for challenging enforceability.

The precise terms of the guarantee are critical.

Some guarantees are limited to a particular facility or amount, while others contain extensive provisions covering present and future liabilities.

A guarantee may also include an indemnity, which can give the creditor additional contractual rights.

At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we can review the guarantee, assess the creditor's claim and advise on the available defences or opportunities for settlement.

What is wrongful trading?

Wrongful trading is a statutory basis upon which a director may be required to contribute personally to the assets of an insolvent company.

The principal provision concerning companies in insolvent liquidation is section 214 of the Insolvency Act 1986.

A corresponding provision, section 246ZB, applies in relation to insolvent administration.

Broadly, wrongful trading may arise where a director knew, or ought to have concluded, that there was no reasonable prospect of the company avoiding insolvent liquidation or insolvent administration, but failed to take the steps required to minimise potential loss to creditors.

The court may order the director to make a contribution to the company's assets.

However, wrongful trading is not established merely because a company continued trading while experiencing financial difficulties.

The statutory requirements must be satisfied.

Does continuing to trade while insolvent amount to wrongful trading?

Not necessarily.

A company may experience temporary financial difficulties while still having a realistic prospect of recovery.

For example, a company may be awaiting payment from customers, negotiating refinancing or seeking investment.

The law does not automatically require directors to cease trading whenever the company becomes unable to pay a particular debt.

The important question is whether, at the relevant time, the director knew or ought to have concluded that there was no reasonable prospect of avoiding insolvent liquidation or administration.

The court will consider what a reasonably diligent person with the general knowledge, skill and experience expected of a director would have concluded, together with the actual knowledge, skill and experience of the particular director.

The relevant circumstances must be examined as they existed at the time, rather than solely with the benefit of hindsight.

What defence is available to a wrongful trading claim?

Section 214 provides an important statutory protection.

A director will not be ordered to contribute under that section if the court is satisfied that, after the relevant point was reached, the director took every step they ought to have taken with a view to minimising the potential loss to the company's creditors.

Relevant evidence may include:

  • Obtaining professional financial or insolvency advice.

  • Preparing and reviewing cash-flow forecasts.

  • Monitoring the company's financial position.

  • Seeking realistic refinancing or investment.

  • Taking steps to reduce unnecessary expenditure.

  • Avoiding transactions which would improperly prejudice creditors.

  • Keeping proper records of board discussions and decisions.

  • Considering formal insolvency procedures where appropriate.

Whether these steps are sufficient will depend upon the circumstances.

The existence of financial difficulties or the ultimate failure of a rescue attempt does not automatically establish wrongful trading.

What is fraudulent trading?

Fraudulent trading is a more serious allegation than wrongful trading.

Under section 213 of the Insolvency Act 1986, the court may order a person who was knowingly party to carrying on the company's business with intent to defraud creditors, or for another fraudulent purpose, to contribute to the company's assets.

Fraudulent trading requires proof of dishonesty.

It is not sufficient merely to establish that the company was insolvent, that creditors were unpaid or that the directors made poor commercial decisions.

The claimant must establish the relevant fraudulent conduct and the defendant's knowing participation.

Unlike wrongful trading, liability for fraudulent trading is not confined to directors.

Other individuals who knowingly participated in the fraudulent conduct may also face liability.

Fraudulent trading may also give rise to criminal consequences under separate statutory provisions.

Given the seriousness of the allegation, the evidence must be examined carefully.

Can a liquidator sue a director for breach of duty?

Yes.

Directors owe statutory and fiduciary duties to the company.

These include duties under the Companies Act 2006 to act within their powers, promote the success of the company, exercise independent judgment, exercise reasonable care, skill and diligence, and avoid certain conflicts of interest.

Where a director breaches those duties and causes loss to the company, the company may have a claim against the director.

Following liquidation, the liquidator may pursue claims belonging to the company.

Section 212 of the Insolvency Act 1986 provides a procedure through which the court may examine allegations of misfeasance or breach of duty involving directors and certain other persons.

The court may order repayment, restoration of property or compensation where the statutory requirements are established.

What conduct might amount to misfeasance?

Examples may include:

  • Using company funds for personal purposes without proper authority.

  • Transferring company assets for inadequate consideration in breach of duty.

  • Making payments to directors without a proper legal basis.

  • Causing the company to enter transactions involving undisclosed conflicts of interest.

  • Misapplying money belonging to the company.

  • Making unlawful distributions to shareholders.

  • Failing to exercise reasonable care and skill in circumstances causing loss to the company.

However, not every unsuccessful business decision constitutes a breach of duty.

Directors are permitted to make commercial judgments and take legitimate business risks.

A liquidator must establish the relevant breach and the basis upon which the director should be required to provide a remedy.

The existence and amount of any recoverable loss may also be disputed.

Can a director be sued for an overdrawn director's loan account?

Yes.

An overdrawn director's loan account is a common source of claims following company liquidation.

A director's loan account records financial transactions between the company and the director.

Where the director has withdrawn more money from the company than they were entitled to receive as salary, dividends, expenses or other properly authorised payments, the account may show a balance owed by the director to the company.

If the company enters liquidation, the liquidator may seek repayment of that balance.

Does an overdrawn loan account automatically mean the director owes the money?

Not necessarily.

The company's accounting records are important evidence, but the underlying transactions must be considered.

Disputes may arise concerning:

  • Whether the withdrawals were correctly recorded.

  • Whether payments represented salary, dividends or reimbursement of expenses.

  • Whether the director had previously advanced funds to the company.

  • Whether credits or repayments have been omitted.

  • Whether accounting adjustments were properly made.

  • Whether dividends were validly declared.

  • Whether the balance claimed is accurate.

For example, a director may dispute a liquidator's calculation because payments recorded as loans were actually legitimate business expenses.

Alternatively, the director may contend that sums advanced to the company have not been properly credited.

It may be necessary to examine the company's accounting records, bank statements, dividend documentation and other financial evidence.

At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we can review claims concerning directors' loan accounts, identify potential disputes and assist in negotiating or defending repayment demands.

Can a liquidator recover dividends paid to directors or shareholders?

Potentially, yes.

A company may only make distributions in accordance with the applicable requirements of the Companies Act 2006.

In particular, dividends must be supported by sufficient profits available for distribution, assessed in accordance with the statutory rules.

Where a dividend has been paid unlawfully, the company or liquidator may have grounds to seek recovery.

Section 847 of the Companies Act 2006 provides for repayment by a shareholder who knew, or had reasonable grounds for believing, that the distribution was made in contravention of the statutory requirements.

A director who authorised an unlawful distribution may also face a claim for breach of duty, depending on the circumstances.

However, the fact that a company subsequently becomes insolvent does not automatically mean that earlier dividends were unlawful.

The financial position and applicable requirements at the time of the distribution must be examined.

The documentation supporting the dividend may be important, including relevant accounts, board minutes and dividend vouchers.

Can a director be personally liable for paying one creditor before another?

Not automatically.

Companies experiencing financial difficulties frequently face difficult decisions about which creditors to pay.

The mere fact that one creditor receives payment while another remains unpaid does not, by itself, establish personal liability on the part of a director.

However, payments made when a company is insolvent may be scrutinised by a subsequently appointed liquidator.

Under section 239 of the Insolvency Act 1986, certain transactions may constitute preferences where the statutory requirements are met.

A preference may arise where a company does something which places a creditor, surety or guarantor in a better position in the event of insolvent liquidation than they would otherwise have occupied, and the other statutory conditions are satisfied.

An important requirement is that the company was influenced by a desire to produce the preferential effect, subject to the statutory presumption applicable to certain connected persons.

What if the company repays a debt personally guaranteed by a director?

This situation requires particular care.

Where a director has personally guaranteed a company debt, repayment of that creditor may reduce or eliminate the director's personal exposure.

If the company is insolvent, a liquidator may investigate whether the repayment constituted a preference.

The fact that a director benefited from the payment does not automatically establish that the transaction is recoverable or that the director is personally liable.

The statutory requirements, the circumstances of the payment and the identity of the appropriate respondent must be considered.

There may also be separate issues concerning the director's duties to the company.

What are transactions at an undervalue?

Under section 238 of the Insolvency Act 1986, certain transactions entered into by a company before insolvency may be challenged where the company received no consideration or consideration significantly less than the value it provided.

For example, a liquidator may investigate the transfer of valuable company property to a director, shareholder or connected business for substantially less than its market value.

Where the statutory requirements are satisfied, the court may make orders designed to restore the position.

However, the existence of a transaction at an undervalue does not automatically mean that every director involved is personally liable for the value of the transaction.

The available remedies and the persons against whom orders may be made depend upon the circumstances.

A director may also face a separate allegation of breach of duty where the transaction improperly depleted the company's assets.

The timing of the transaction, the consideration provided, the company's financial position and the commercial justification may all be relevant.

When must directors consider the interests of creditors?

Directors' duties can change in emphasis as a company's financial difficulties become more serious.

The leading Supreme Court decision is BTI 2014 LLC v Sequana SA [2022] UKSC 25.

The Supreme Court confirmed that, in certain circumstances, directors must take account of the interests of the company's creditors as a whole when performing their duty to act in the interests of the company.

This principle is recognised by section 172(3) of the Companies Act 2006.

The duty remains owed to the company rather than becoming a separate duty owed directly to individual creditors.

The Supreme Court rejected the proposition that a mere real risk of insolvency at some future date was sufficient to engage the creditor-interest duty.

The relevant circumstances include actual insolvency, imminent insolvency or probable insolvent liquidation or administration, with the precise application depending on the facts.

As the company's financial difficulties become more serious, greater weight must be given to creditors' interests.

Where insolvent liquidation or administration becomes inevitable, creditors' interests become paramount.

What does this mean for directors in practice?

Directors should pay close attention to the company's financial position when serious difficulties arise.

They should consider whether continued trading is realistically capable of improving the position or whether it is likely to increase losses.

They should also be cautious about transactions which benefit directors, shareholders or connected parties at the expense of creditors generally.

Obtaining timely professional advice and maintaining proper records of decisions may be particularly important.

However, the law does not impose personal liability simply because a director attempted unsuccessfully to rescue a struggling company.

The circumstances, the director's conduct and the relevant legal requirements must all be considered.

Can a director be personally liable for unpaid tax debts?

Ordinarily, tax liabilities incurred by a limited company are debts of the company.

However, there are statutory exceptions under which HMRC may pursue directors or other individuals personally.

For example, personal liability may arise in certain circumstances involving unpaid National Insurance contributions, tax avoidance or evasion, or repeated insolvency and non-payment of tax liabilities.

The relevant powers are subject to specific statutory conditions and procedures.

A director does not become personally liable for all unpaid corporation tax, VAT or PAYE simply because the company enters liquidation.

Where HMRC seeks to impose personal liability, the precise statutory basis for the demand should be identified and examined.

This is distinct from a liquidator's claim for wrongful trading or breach of duty.

Can a creditor sue a director personally without a guarantee?

Sometimes, but the creditor must establish an independent basis for personal liability.

For example, a director may incur personal liability where they have personally committed a tort, made an actionable fraudulent misrepresentation or entered into a contract in their own name.

However, merely acting on behalf of a company does not ordinarily make a director liable for the company's contractual obligations.

The creditor must establish that the director personally owed and breached a relevant legal duty, made a binding contractual commitment or otherwise incurred liability.

The courts do not generally disregard a company's separate legal personality simply because the company cannot pay its debts.

The circumstances in which the corporate veil may be pierced are narrow.

Accordingly, a creditor cannot ordinarily circumvent the company's limited liability merely by alleging that its directors controlled the business or made the decisions which led to the debt.

Can a director be disqualified if the company becomes insolvent?

Potentially, yes, but director disqualification is separate from personal financial liability.

Under the Company Directors Disqualification Act 1986, directors may face disqualification proceedings where their conduct makes them unfit to be concerned in the management of a company.

The relevant conduct may include serious failures concerning company accounting records, tax obligations, treatment of creditors or other aspects of company management.

However, the failure of a company does not automatically mean that its directors are unfit.

Disqualification proceedings concern whether the individual should be restricted from acting as a director or participating in company management.

A disqualification order does not, by itself, establish that the director is personally liable for every unpaid company debt.

There are also statutory provisions under which compensation may be sought in certain circumstances connected with disqualification.

Where a director faces both a financial claim and potential disqualification proceedings, the issues should be considered separately.

What happens when a liquidator investigates the directors?

Following liquidation, the liquidator will investigate the company's financial affairs and may examine transactions involving its directors.

The liquidator may request accounting records, bank statements, contracts and explanations concerning particular payments or decisions.

The liquidator may also examine directors' loan accounts, dividends, asset transfers and transactions with connected parties.

Where potential claims are identified, the liquidator or solicitors acting on the liquidator's behalf may send a letter alleging wrongdoing and demanding repayment or compensation.

However, the fact that a liquidator raises questions or makes allegations does not mean that personal liability has been established.

The director is entitled to understand the legal basis of the claim and the evidence relied upon.

A properly formulated claim should identify the relevant transactions, alleged breaches and remedy sought.

How can a director defend a claim brought by a liquidator?

The appropriate defence will depend on the nature of the claim.

A director facing a wrongful trading allegation may dispute when it became apparent that insolvent liquidation or administration could not reasonably be avoided, or rely on steps taken to minimise creditor losses.

A director facing a misfeasance claim may dispute the alleged breach of duty, the loss claimed or the causal connection between the two.

Where the claim concerns a director's loan account, the director may challenge the accuracy of the accounting records or identify omitted credits.

Where transactions at an undervalue or preferences are alleged, it may be necessary to examine the statutory conditions, the relevant time periods and the commercial circumstances of the transactions.

What evidence may assist a director?

Depending on the allegations, relevant evidence may include:

  • Board minutes and contemporaneous records of decisions.

  • Management accounts and financial forecasts.

  • Correspondence with accountants and professional advisers.

  • Bank statements and accounting records.

  • Loan agreements and dividend documentation.

  • Contracts and commercial correspondence.

  • Evidence of attempts to refinance or rescue the business.

  • Documents explaining the commercial purpose of disputed transactions.

  • Records of payments made to or on behalf of the company.

Contemporaneous evidence can be particularly important.

The court will ordinarily need to assess the director's conduct by reference to what was known, or ought reasonably to have been known, at the relevant time.

Can claims against directors be settled?

Yes.

Many claims arising from company insolvency can be resolved through negotiation without a contested trial.

For example, a liquidator may be willing to negotiate repayment of a disputed director's loan account or compromise a claim concerning alleged breach of duty.

The terms of settlement will depend upon the strength of the claim, the available evidence, the amount in dispute and the commercial circumstances.

However, directors should not assume that a demand from a liquidator necessarily represents the amount legally recoverable.

The claim should first be assessed to establish whether the alleged liability is properly founded.

Equally, a director should not ignore correspondence from a liquidator or assume that the matter will disappear.

Where proceedings are threatened, it may be possible to negotiate a practical resolution before substantial additional legal costs are incurred.

At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we can assess the claim, prepare a substantive response and negotiate settlement where appropriate.

Can directors be jointly liable?

Potentially, yes.

Where more than one director has participated in conduct giving rise to liability, claims may be pursued against multiple individuals.

For example, several directors may be alleged to have authorised transactions in breach of duty or participated in wrongful trading.

However, liability is not necessarily identical for every director.

The court will consider the relevant statutory requirements and each individual's conduct, knowledge, responsibilities and involvement.

A director cannot automatically avoid responsibility by arguing that another director dealt with the company's finances.

Equally, the fact that a person held office as a director does not mean that they are automatically responsible for every decision made by the company.

The individual circumstances require careful assessment.

What if a director has resigned before the company enters liquidation?

Resignation does not necessarily eliminate liability for conduct occurring while the individual was a director.

For example, a former director may still face a claim concerning an earlier breach of duty or a transaction entered into during their period of office.

Similarly, wrongful trading provisions can apply to former directors where the statutory requirements are satisfied.

However, a director is not ordinarily responsible for subsequent decisions merely because they previously held office.

The timing of the alleged wrongdoing and the individual's actual involvement will be important.

Resignation should therefore not be regarded as an automatic solution to existing potential liabilities.

Can a director lose their home because of company debts?

Potentially, but only where there is a proper basis for personal liability.

A company creditor cannot ordinarily enforce a company debt against a director's home merely because the company is insolvent.

However, where a director has given an enforceable personal guarantee or becomes subject to a personal judgment, the creditor may be able to pursue enforcement against the director's personal assets.

Depending on the circumstances, enforcement may include a charging order against property or bankruptcy proceedings.

Similarly, a liquidator who obtains a judgment against a director may seek to enforce that judgment.

The risks will depend on the nature of the liability, the amount involved and the director's personal financial circumstances.

Early advice may be particularly important where a director faces a substantial personal guarantee claim or proceedings brought by a liquidator.

How much does it cost to defend a claim against a director?

The legal costs will depend upon the nature of the claim, the amount involved and the complexity of the issues.

A relatively straightforward dispute concerning a director's loan account may be capable of resolution through correspondence and negotiation.

Other cases may involve extensive financial evidence, allegations of breach of duty or complex wrongful trading claims requiring specialist counsel and expert accounting evidence.

Our work may include:

  • Reviewing the liquidator's allegations and supporting documents.

  • Identifying the legal basis of the claim.

  • Examining accounting records and financial transactions.

  • Advising on personal guarantees.

  • Assessing allegations of wrongful trading or misfeasance.

  • Preparing responses to letters before action.

  • Negotiating settlement.

  • Preparing a defence to court proceedings.

  • Instructing specialist insolvency counsel.

  • Working with forensic accountants or other experts where appropriate.

We will provide an estimate of our fees after reviewing the circumstances.

Where specialist counsel or expert evidence is required, the additional costs will be explained before instructions are given.

How Bowman Abraham Solicitors can assist

At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we advise directors facing personal claims arising from company insolvency.

Our experience in commercial litigation, contractual disputes and contentious insolvency enables us to consider both the legal basis of a claim and the underlying financial or commercial transactions.

We can assist with:

  • Defending claims under personal guarantees.

  • Disputing claims concerning directors' loan accounts.

  • Defending allegations of wrongful trading.

  • Responding to misfeasance and breach of duty claims.

  • Advising on disputed dividends and director remuneration.

  • Defending claims involving preferences and transactions at an undervalue.

  • Negotiating with liquidators and creditors.

  • Preparing responses to threatened proceedings.

  • Defending contested court claims.

  • Arranging specialist insolvency counsel where appropriate.

We recognise that claims against directors can involve substantial personal financial exposure.

Our objective is to assess the allegations carefully, identify the available defences and seek the most favourable outcome reasonably achievable, whether through negotiation or contested proceedings.

Speak to a solicitor about personal liability for company debts

If your company has entered liquidation, or you have received a demand from a creditor or liquidator seeking to hold you personally liable, it is important to obtain advice promptly.

A company's insolvency does not automatically make its directors responsible for its debts.

Personal liability must be established by reference to a recognised legal basis, and there may be substantial grounds for challenging the allegations or the amount claimed.

Bowman Abraham Solicitors can review the circumstances, advise on your personal exposure and assist in defending or resolving the claim.

Michael Abraham — Partner

07813 493391

michael.abraham@bowman-abraham.co.uk

Bowman Abraham Solicitors

020 3732 0424

This article provides general information about the law of England and Wales and does not constitute legal advice on individual circumstances.