Receiving a bankruptcy petition is a serious matter. If the petition succeeds, the court may make a bankruptcy order which can have significant consequences for your finances, property, business interests and family home.
However, the presentation of a bankruptcy petition does not mean that a bankruptcy order is inevitable.
There may be grounds to oppose the petition, particularly where the debt is disputed, the debtor has a substantial counterclaim, the statutory requirements have not been satisfied, or the debtor can demonstrate an ability to pay.
At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we advise individuals facing bankruptcy petitions, including those involving disputed debts, procedural irregularities and urgent concerns about the family home.
We can also assist in negotiating settlements and payment arrangements to prevent bankruptcy proceedings from progressing.
What is a bankruptcy petition?
A bankruptcy petition is a formal application to the court seeking a bankruptcy order against an individual.
A creditor may present a petition where the statutory requirements are satisfied, including the requirement that the debt, or aggregate debts, must generally amount to at least £5,000.
The petitioning creditor must also establish the debtor's inability to pay in accordance with the Insolvency Act 1986.
This is commonly done by relying on a statutory demand which has not been complied with within 21 days, although other statutory grounds may apply.
The court will consider whether the legal requirements for making a bankruptcy order have been met and whether there are grounds for dismissing or adjourning the petition.
On what grounds can a bankruptcy petition be opposed?
The appropriate grounds will depend on the circumstances.
Common grounds for opposing a bankruptcy petition include:
The petition debt is genuinely disputed on substantial grounds.
The debtor has a substantial counterclaim, set-off or cross-demand.
The debt has already been paid or discharged.
The debtor is able to pay their debts and bankruptcy is inappropriate.
A reasonable offer to pay, secure or compromise the debt has been unreasonably refused.
The statutory requirements for presenting the petition have not been satisfied.
There have been significant procedural irregularities, including defective service.
The petition constitutes an improper use of insolvency proceedings.
It is important to identify the strongest available grounds and support them with appropriate documentary evidence.
1. The debt is genuinely disputed
One of the most important grounds for opposing a bankruptcy petition is that the underlying debt is genuinely disputed on substantial grounds.
Bankruptcy proceedings are not intended to be used as a substitute for ordinary civil litigation where there is a substantial dispute about whether a debt is owed.
For example, a petition may be opposed where:
The debtor denies entering into the alleged agreement.
There is a substantial dispute concerning the creditor's performance of contractual obligations.
The amount claimed is incorrectly calculated.
The debtor alleges that the creditor has fundamentally breached the contract.
The creditor's entitlement to payment depends on disputed facts or legal issues.
The debtor does not ordinarily need to establish conclusively that they will succeed in defending the debt claim. However, they must demonstrate that there are substantial grounds for disputing it.
A bare denial of liability, unsupported by evidence, will not normally be sufficient.
What happens to the debt if the bankruptcy petition is dismissed?
Dismissal of a bankruptcy petition does not necessarily mean that the underlying debt has been extinguished.
Where a petition is dismissed because the debt is genuinely disputed, the creditor may still pursue the claim through ordinary civil proceedings.
The dispute can then be determined through the normal litigation process, with the parties having an opportunity to present evidence and obtain a judgment.
The distinction is important: a creditor should not use the threat of bankruptcy to bypass the ordinary process for determining a substantial dispute.
2. The debtor has a substantial counterclaim or set-off
A bankruptcy petition may also be opposed where the debtor has a genuine and substantial counterclaim, set-off or cross-demand against the petitioning creditor.
For example, a creditor may claim £30,000 under a commercial agreement, but the debtor may have a substantial claim for damages arising from the creditor's breach of that agreement.
If the counterclaim is genuine and sufficiently substantial, it may provide grounds for opposing the petition.
The court will consider the nature of the counterclaim, the evidence supporting it and whether it is sufficient to affect the creditor's entitlement to pursue bankruptcy proceedings.
A counterclaim should not be advanced merely as a tactical response to the petition. It must have a proper factual and legal basis.
3. The debtor is able to pay their debts
A bankruptcy petition is intended to address insolvency, rather than simply to provide an alternative means of enforcing payment against someone who has the ability to meet their liabilities.
Under section 271 of the Insolvency Act 1986, the court has power to dismiss a creditor's petition where it is satisfied that the debtor is able to pay all their debts.
However, the mere fact that the debtor owns valuable assets does not necessarily mean that they are able to pay.
For example, an individual may own a property with substantial equity but have insufficient cash or readily available finance to discharge the petition debt.
The court will be concerned with the debtor's actual financial position and ability to meet their liabilities, rather than simply the value of their assets on paper.
What evidence can demonstrate an ability to pay?
Relevant evidence may include:
Bank statements demonstrating available funds.
Evidence of readily accessible savings or investments.
Confirmation of an agreed loan or finance facility.
Evidence of funds available from a third party.
Evidence that the debt has been paid or that payment can be completed promptly.
A statement of assets and liabilities demonstrating the debtor's wider financial position.
The availability of finance must be realistic and supported by evidence. A speculative possibility of obtaining a loan or selling a property at some future date may be insufficient.
It is also important to distinguish between an ability to pay the petition debt and an ability to pay debts generally.
Where the debtor can demonstrate that they are solvent and have the means to satisfy their liabilities, there may be a substantial basis for opposing the petition.
4. A reasonable offer to pay or secure the debt has been refused
A debtor may accept that the petition debt is due but nevertheless have grounds to seek dismissal of the petition where an appropriate offer to secure or compromise the debt has been unreasonably refused.
Section 271(3) of the Insolvency Act 1986 gives the court a discretion to dismiss a petition in certain circumstances where the debtor has made an offer to secure or compound for the debt and the creditor has unreasonably refused it.
The court will consider whether the offer was sufficient, whether acceptance would have required dismissal of the petition and whether the creditor's refusal was unreasonable.
For example, a debtor may offer adequate security over an asset or propose a properly evidenced arrangement which would protect the creditor's position.
However, simply offering to pay the debt by instalments does not automatically entitle the debtor to have the petition dismissed.
The terms of the offer, the debtor's financial circumstances and the creditor's legitimate interests will all be relevant.
5. The statutory requirements have not been satisfied
A bankruptcy petition must comply with the statutory requirements contained principally in sections 267 and 268 of the Insolvency Act 1986.
Depending on the circumstances, grounds for opposing a petition may include:
The qualifying debt threshold has not been met.
The debt does not satisfy the applicable statutory requirements.
The creditor has failed to establish the debtor's inability to pay.
The statutory demand relied upon is invalid or was not properly served.
The petition has been presented in circumstances where the creditor was not entitled to do so.
These issues require careful consideration of the petition, the statutory demand where applicable, and the evidence relied upon by the creditor.
A failure to comply with a statutory requirement may provide a substantial basis for opposing the petition.
6. Procedural irregularities and defective service
A bankruptcy petition must be served in accordance with the applicable Insolvency Rules.
Personal service is ordinarily required, although the court may authorise alternative methods of service in appropriate circumstances.
If the petition has not been properly served, or the debtor has not been given the required opportunity to respond, this may provide grounds for opposing or seeking an adjournment of the petition.
However, not every procedural irregularity will necessarily result in dismissal.
The court may consider whether the defect can be remedied, whether the debtor has suffered prejudice and whether the statutory requirements can otherwise be satisfied.
For example, defective service may justify an adjournment to allow the debtor a proper opportunity to respond, rather than dismissal of the petition altogether.
The distinction is particularly important where the underlying debt is undisputed and the debtor has no realistic means of paying it.
A procedural objection may be relevant, but it should not be assumed that a technical defect will automatically prevent a bankruptcy order.
What should you do if you have received a bankruptcy petition?
It is important to act promptly and not wait until the hearing date before obtaining advice.
The first step is to review the petition and supporting documents, including any statutory demand, judgment or other evidence relied upon by the creditor.
The debtor should then consider whether the debt is disputed, whether there are counterclaims or set-offs, and whether the debt can be paid, secured or otherwise resolved.
Where the petition is to be opposed, the grounds should be identified and supported by evidence before the hearing.
Is there a deadline for opposing a bankruptcy petition?
Yes.
Under rule 10.18 of the Insolvency (England and Wales) Rules 2016, a debtor who intends to oppose the making of a bankruptcy order must, not less than five business days before the hearing:
File a notice of opposition with the court.
Deliver a copy to the petitioning creditor or the creditor's solicitor.
The notice must identify the proceedings, state that the debtor intends to oppose the bankruptcy order and set out the grounds of opposition.
This is an important procedural requirement. The debtor should also prepare and file any supporting evidence in accordance with the applicable rules and directions.
Where the deadline is approaching or has already passed, urgent legal advice should be obtained. The court's willingness to consider late material or grant an adjournment cannot be assumed.
What happens at the bankruptcy petition hearing?
At the hearing, the court will consider the petition and any opposition raised by the debtor.
The petitioning creditor will seek to establish that the statutory requirements for making a bankruptcy order have been satisfied.
The debtor may seek to demonstrate that the petition should be dismissed or adjourned.
Depending on the circumstances, the court may:
Make a bankruptcy order.
Dismiss the petition.
Adjourn the hearing to allow further evidence, payment or other steps to be taken.
Make an appropriate costs order.
The outcome will depend on the evidence, the applicable law and the particular circumstances.
Can the hearing be adjourned?
Yes. The court has discretion to adjourn a bankruptcy petition hearing.
An adjournment may be appropriate where there is a genuine prospect of resolving the debt, further evidence is required, or the debtor needs a reasonable opportunity to address an issue affecting the petition.
For example, a short adjournment may be sought where a debtor has obtained a mortgage offer or other finance and completion is expected shortly.
However, an adjournment is not automatic.
The court will consider whether there is a realistic prospect of resolving the matter, the history of the proceedings, the creditor's position and any previous adjournments.
Repeated requests for additional time without credible evidence of progress may be unsuccessful.
Can you negotiate with the creditor to avoid bankruptcy?
In many cases, negotiations may provide a more practical solution than contested proceedings.
Depending on the circumstances, it may be possible to negotiate:
Payment of the outstanding debt and recoverable petition costs.
A settlement for an agreed sum.
An arrangement to secure the debt.
A short period to complete refinancing or a property transaction.
Withdrawal or dismissal of the petition by agreement.
Where a settlement is reached, it is important to ensure that the arrangements for dealing with the petition are properly documented and that any necessary court orders are obtained.
The mere fact that the petitioning creditor has agreed to withdraw does not necessarily mean that the court will automatically dispose of the petition, particularly where other creditors have become involved.
What if you own a property but cannot immediately pay the debt?
This is a common situation.
An individual may have substantial equity in their family home but insufficient liquid funds to discharge the petition debt immediately.
Depending on the available equity and financial circumstances, it may be possible to arrange refinancing, specialist lending or third-party funding to discharge the debt and avoid bankruptcy.
However, any proposed funding must be realistic and achievable within an appropriate timescale.
Where bankruptcy proceedings are already underway, lenders may require additional information or impose conditions before advancing funds.
Early advice can be particularly important, as arranging finance after a bankruptcy order has been made may be substantially more complicated.
What happens if a bankruptcy order is made?
If the court makes a bankruptcy order, the consequences can be significant.
The Official Receiver will become involved in the bankruptcy, and a trustee in bankruptcy may be appointed to administer the bankrupt's estate.
Certain assets, including the bankrupt's beneficial interest in property, may vest in the trustee.
This can ultimately place the family home at risk, depending on the ownership arrangements, available equity and other circumstances.
A bankruptcy order may also affect business interests, creditworthiness and the ability to act as a company director.
Can a bankruptcy order be challenged after it has been made?
Yes, in certain circumstances.
If a bankruptcy order has already been made, it may be possible to apply for annulment under section 282 of the Insolvency Act 1986.
For example, an annulment may be sought where the bankruptcy order ought not to have been made or where the bankruptcy debts and expenses have been paid or secured to the satisfaction of the court.
However, opposing a petition before a bankruptcy order is made will generally be preferable to attempting to reverse the consequences afterwards.
Our separate guide, Annulment of a Bankruptcy Order, explains the available grounds and procedure in greater detail.
Can you recover your legal costs if the petition is dismissed?
The court has discretion to make costs orders in bankruptcy proceedings.
Where a petition is dismissed because the debt was genuinely disputed or the creditor was not entitled to present it, the debtor may seek an order requiring the petitioning creditor to pay the costs of opposing the petition.
However, recovery is not automatic and will depend on the circumstances and the court's decision.
The court may take into account the parties' conduct, the basis on which the petition was presented, the grounds of opposition and any reasonable settlement offers.
Even where a costs order is made, the amount ultimately recovered may be less than the legal costs actually incurred.
How much does it cost to oppose a bankruptcy petition?
The costs will depend on the grounds of opposition, the complexity of the issues, the evidence required and whether the petition is resolved by agreement or proceeds to a contested hearing.
We will provide an estimate after reviewing the petition and the circumstances of the case.
For budgeting purposes, the following are proposed indicative figures for the initial stages:
| Item | Indicative cost |
|---|---|
| Initial review of the petition and advice on the grounds of opposition | £300–£500 |
| Preparing the notice of opposition and supporting evidence | £1,000–£1,500 |
| Total estimated initial legal fees | £1,300–£2,000 |
These estimates exclude VAT where applicable and any additional disbursements.
Preparation for and attendance at the bankruptcy petition hearing, together with any counsel's fees, will be estimated separately.
Where the petition is heavily contested, substantial evidence is required or the hearing is adjourned, additional costs may arise.
The figures above are indicative rather than fixed fees. We will provide a more specific estimate once we have considered the documents and identified the work required.
How Bowman Abraham Solicitors can assist
We advise and represent individuals facing bankruptcy petitions, including in relation to:
Reviewing bankruptcy petitions and identifying grounds of opposition.
Disputing debts relied upon in insolvency proceedings.
Advising on counterclaims, set-offs and cross-demands.
Assessing solvency and preparing evidence of the ability to pay.
Challenging defective statutory demands and procedural irregularities.
Preparing notices of opposition and supporting witness statements.
Negotiating settlements and payment arrangements with petitioning creditors.
Seeking adjournments where there is a realistic prospect of payment or refinancing.
Arranging representation at contested bankruptcy petition hearings.
Advising on urgent steps to protect the family home.
Applications to annul bankruptcy orders where an order has already been made.
Our approach is to identify the most effective means of preventing an unnecessary bankruptcy order, while considering the legal merits, the client's financial position and the practical prospects of resolving the debt.
Speak to a solicitor
If you have been served with a bankruptcy petition, early legal advice can make a substantial difference.
It is important to act before the hearing, particularly where there are grounds for disputing the debt, evidence of an ability to pay or a realistic prospect of negotiating a settlement.
Michael Abraham — Partner
michael.abraham@bowman-abraham.co.uk
Bowman Abraham Solicitors
This article provides general information about the law of England and Wales and does not constitute legal advice on individual circumstances.
