A statutory demand is a formal demand for payment of a debt. If you have received one, it is important to act promptly. Failure to deal with it may allow the creditor to commence bankruptcy proceedings against you.
However, a statutory demand can be challenged, particularly where the debt is genuinely disputed or there are other substantial grounds for opposing it.
At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we advise clients facing statutory demands, disputed debts and threatened bankruptcy proceedings.
What is a statutory demand?
A statutory demand is commonly used by creditors as a preliminary step towards bankruptcy proceedings.
Under sections 267 and 268 of the Insolvency Act 1986, a creditor may, subject to certain conditions, seek a bankruptcy order where an individual owes a qualifying debt of at least £5,000 and is unable to pay it.
One way of establishing an apparent inability to pay is by serving a statutory demand and allowing the required period to expire without payment or a successful challenge.
A statutory demand is not itself a bankruptcy petition or bankruptcy order, but it should never be ignored.
How long do I have to challenge a statutory demand?
You ordinarily have 18 days from service to apply to the court to have a statutory demand set aside.
If the demand is not complied with or set aside, the creditor may ordinarily present a bankruptcy petition after 21 days, provided the statutory conditions are satisfied.
An application made within the relevant period can prevent the creditor from relying on the demand while the application is being dealt with.
If the deadline has already passed, it may still be possible to apply for an extension of time. However, urgent advice is essential.
On what grounds can a statutory demand be set aside?
The principal grounds are set out in rule 10.5 of the Insolvency (England and Wales) Rules 2016.
The debt is genuinely disputed
A statutory demand may be set aside where the debt is disputed on substantial grounds.
For example, you may dispute liability under a contract, challenge the amount claimed, or contend that the creditor has failed to perform its own contractual obligations.
The court will consider whether there is a genuine and substantial dispute. Simply denying that money is owed will not normally be sufficient.
You have a counterclaim or set-off
You may have a claim against the creditor which equals or exceeds the amount demanded.
This commonly arises in commercial disputes where one party claims payment while the other alleges breaches of contract or losses arising from the same relationship.
The creditor holds security
Where the creditor already holds security for the debt, the nature and value of that security may provide grounds for challenging the demand.
Other circumstances
The court also has discretion to set aside a statutory demand where there are other sufficient grounds.
This may include serious procedural defects or circumstances in which insolvency proceedings are being used improperly to exert pressure over a disputed debt.
What happens if I apply to set aside the demand?
An application is made to the court, supported by a witness statement explaining why the demand should be set aside.
The creditor may oppose the application, and the court may arrange a hearing to determine the dispute.
If the application succeeds, the statutory demand will be set aside. However, this does not necessarily mean that the underlying debt has been extinguished. The creditor may still pursue an ordinary civil claim.
If the application is unsuccessful, the creditor may be permitted to proceed with a bankruptcy petition.
How much does it cost to set aside a statutory demand?
The legal costs depend on the complexity of the dispute, the evidence required and whether the application is contested.
A relatively straightforward application may involve reviewing the statutory demand, advising on the merits, preparing the application and supporting witness statement, and attending a hearing.
More complicated matters may require extensive documentary evidence, additional witness statements, written submissions or representation by counsel.
We will provide an estimate based on the circumstances of your case and explain any additional costs that may arise.
Can I recover my legal costs?
If your application succeeds, you may be entitled to seek an order requiring the creditor to pay your legal costs.
The court has discretion when making costs orders, and success does not necessarily mean that every pound spent will be recovered.
Equally, if your application fails, you may be ordered to pay some or all of the creditor's costs.
We will advise you on the potential costs consequences before proceedings are commenced.
What if the statutory demand is against a company?
The procedure is different where a statutory demand is served on a company.
A company facing threatened winding-up proceedings in respect of a genuinely disputed debt may be able to seek an injunction restraining the creditor from presenting or advertising a winding-up petition.
We also advise companies facing winding-up threats and disputed corporate debts.
How Bowman Abraham Solicitors can help
We can assist by reviewing the demand, identifying grounds for challenge, advising on the available options and preparing the necessary court application and evidence.
Where appropriate, we can also negotiate with the creditor to seek a resolution without contested proceedings.
Our approach is to identify the central issues quickly, assess the merits realistically and pursue a proportionate strategy.
Speak to a solicitor
If you have received a statutory demand, early advice is important.
Michael Abraham — Partner
michael.abraham@bowman-abraham.co.uk
Bowman Abraham Solicitors
This article provides general information about the law of England and Wales and does not constitute legal advice on individual circumstances.
