Where an individual or company fails to pay a substantial debt, a creditor may consider whether insolvency proceedings are appropriate.
A statutory demand can be an important preliminary step. However, insolvency proceedings are not intended to provide an alternative forum for resolving genuinely disputed debts, and creditors must exercise care before threatening bankruptcy or winding-up proceedings.
At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we advise creditors on statutory demands, bankruptcy petitions, winding-up petitions and the appropriate steps to take where debts remain unpaid.
What is a statutory demand?
A statutory demand is a formal written demand requiring a debtor to pay a debt, secure it or reach an acceptable arrangement with the creditor.
If the debtor does not comply within the prescribed period, the demand may provide evidence of an inability to pay debts for the purposes of insolvency proceedings.
The relevant provisions are found principally in the Insolvency Act 1986.
For individuals, sections 267 and 268 govern important requirements for creditors' bankruptcy petitions.
For companies, section 123 provides circumstances in which a company may be deemed unable to pay its debts, including failure to comply with a qualifying statutory demand.
A statutory demand is not itself a court judgment, bankruptcy petition or winding-up petition.
When is a statutory demand appropriate?
A statutory demand may be appropriate where:
The debt is due and payable.
The amount owed is sufficiently certain.
There is no genuine and substantial dispute about liability.
The relevant insolvency threshold is satisfied.
The creditor is prepared to consider insolvency proceedings if the debt remains unpaid.
Before serving a statutory demand, it is important to assess the underlying debt and any potential defence or counterclaim.
A statutory demand should not be used simply to exert pressure on a debtor to settle a genuinely disputed claim.
Statutory demands against individuals
For an individual debtor, a creditor generally requires a qualifying debt of at least £5,000 to present a bankruptcy petition.
Where the debt is immediately payable, service of a statutory demand may be used to establish the debtor's apparent inability to pay.
The debtor ordinarily has 21 days to comply with the demand. An application to set it aside should ordinarily be made within 18 days of service.
If the demand remains unsatisfied and the statutory conditions are met, the creditor may be entitled to present a bankruptcy petition.
However, a bankruptcy petition is a serious step. The creditor should consider whether it is commercially justified, including whether the debtor has assets from which any eventual recovery may be made.
Statutory demands against companies
Where the debtor is a company, the relevant statutory framework includes section 123 of the Insolvency Act 1986.
A creditor owed more than £750 may serve a statutory demand at the company's registered office. If the company fails for three weeks to pay, secure or compound for the debt to the creditor's reasonable satisfaction, that may establish an inability to pay debts for winding-up purposes.
Unlike an individual, a company does not ordinarily apply to set aside a statutory demand under the personal bankruptcy procedure.
If a company disputes the debt on substantial grounds, it may seek an injunction restraining the presentation or advertisement of a winding-up petition.
A creditor should therefore investigate any genuine dispute before taking steps towards winding up.
What happens after the statutory demand expires?
If the debtor does not pay or otherwise resolve the demand within the relevant period, the creditor must decide whether to take further action.
Depending on the circumstances, the available options may include:
Presenting a bankruptcy petition against an individual.
Presenting a winding-up petition against a company.
Commencing ordinary civil proceedings to establish liability and obtain judgment.
Negotiating a payment arrangement or settlement.
The expiry of a statutory demand does not automatically result in bankruptcy or liquidation.
A creditor must still satisfy the applicable statutory requirements, and the court retains control over whether an insolvency order should be made.
What if the debt is disputed?
Insolvency proceedings should not ordinarily be used to determine a genuinely disputed debt.
Where there is a substantial dispute about liability, the appropriate course may be to commence ordinary civil proceedings so that the court can determine the parties' rights.
The position is different where the debtor merely asserts a dispute without any substantial basis.
The distinction can be important. A creditor who threatens or pursues insolvency proceedings improperly may face an injunction and an adverse costs order.
It is therefore sensible to review the contractual documents, correspondence, payment history and any allegations of set-off or counterclaim before proceeding.
Is a statutory demand always the best approach?
Not necessarily.
A statutory demand may prompt a debtor to engage with the creditor, but that should not obscure its proper insolvency purpose.
If the debtor is solvent but unwilling to pay, ordinary civil proceedings and subsequent enforcement may be more appropriate.
Similarly, obtaining a bankruptcy or winding-up order does not guarantee that the creditor will recover the debt.
Insolvency proceedings generally involve the collective administration of the debtor's assets, with recoveries governed by insolvency priorities and available funds.
Creditors should therefore consider the likely commercial outcome, not simply whether the statutory conditions permit a petition.
How much does it cost?
The costs depend on the nature of the debt, the documents available, the debtor's response and whether insolvency proceedings become necessary.
Preparing and serving a statutory demand
We will normally review the supporting documentation, advise on whether the demand is appropriate, prepare the statutory demand and arrange for service.
We will provide an estimate of our fees once we have reviewed the circumstances and established the work required.
Bankruptcy or winding-up proceedings
If the demand is not satisfied and the creditor wishes to proceed, further costs will arise.
These may include:
Solicitors' fees for preparing and issuing the petition.
Court fees and any required insolvency deposit.
Process-server or other service costs.
Advertisement costs, where applicable.
Counsel's fees for attending a hearing.
Additional costs if the petition is opposed or adjourned.
We will explain the anticipated costs and disbursements before taking the next step.
Can the creditor recover the costs?
A creditor may be able to recover certain costs through the insolvency process, depending on the circumstances and the applicable rules.
However, recovery is not guaranteed. Even where the creditor establishes the debt and obtains an insolvency order, the debtor's assets may be insufficient to satisfy the debt and costs.
The potential costs of unsuccessful or improperly pursued proceedings must also be considered.
How Bowman Abraham Solicitors can assist
We advise creditors on the appropriate use of statutory demands and insolvency proceedings, including:
Assessing whether a debt is suitable for insolvency action.
Preparing and arranging service of statutory demands.
Responding to allegations that the debt is disputed.
Preparing bankruptcy and winding-up petitions.
Negotiating payment arrangements and settlements.
Advising on the risks, costs and likely commercial outcome of proceedings.
Our approach is to assess the strength of the creditor's position and identify the most proportionate means of pursuing recovery.
Speak to a solicitor
If you are owed a substantial undisputed debt and are considering a statutory demand or insolvency proceedings, we can advise on the available options.
Michael Abraham — Partner
michael.abraham@bowman-abraham.co.uk
Bowman Abraham Solicitors
This article provides general information about the law of England and Wales and does not constitute legal advice on individual circumstances.
