Where an individual owes a substantial debt and has failed to pay, a creditor may be entitled to present a bankruptcy petition.
Bankruptcy proceedings can be an effective means of addressing an individual's insolvency, but they are not appropriate in every debt recovery case. Before presenting a petition, creditors should consider whether the statutory requirements are satisfied, whether the debt is genuinely disputed and whether bankruptcy is likely to produce a meaningful financial recovery.
At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we advise creditors on bankruptcy petitions, statutory demands and the appropriate use of insolvency proceedings.
When can a creditor present a bankruptcy petition?
Under section 267 of the Insolvency Act 1986, a creditor may present a bankruptcy petition where the relevant statutory conditions are satisfied.
These include:
The debtor owes a qualifying debt, or debts, totalling at least £5,000.
The debt is for a liquidated sum and is payable immediately or at a certain future time.
The debt is unsecured, or any security is appropriately accounted for.
The debtor appears unable to pay, or has no reasonable prospect of paying, the debt in accordance with the statutory requirements.
The debt must also satisfy the applicable jurisdictional requirements.
A bankruptcy petition should not ordinarily be presented where the debt is genuinely disputed on substantial grounds.
Is a statutory demand necessary before presenting a bankruptcy petition?
A statutory demand is one of the principal methods by which a creditor can establish an individual's apparent inability to pay a debt.
Under section 268 of the Insolvency Act 1986, where an immediately payable debt remains unsatisfied for three weeks following service of a statutory demand, and the demand has not been set aside, this may establish the debtor's apparent inability to pay.
However, a statutory demand is not required in every case.
For example, where a creditor has obtained a judgment and attempted execution or another qualifying enforcement process without successfully recovering the debt, that may provide an alternative statutory basis for presenting a bankruptcy petition.
We can advise on the appropriate route based on the nature of the debt and any previous enforcement action.
What happens when a bankruptcy petition is presented?
The procedure generally involves several stages.
Preparing the petition
The creditor must establish the debt, the statutory basis for the petition and the debtor's connection with the jurisdiction.
The petition must be prepared in the prescribed form and supported by the necessary evidence.
Filing the petition
The petition is presented to the appropriate court, together with the applicable court fee and bankruptcy deposit.
The deposit is intended to contribute towards the costs of administering the bankruptcy if an order is made.
Serving the petition
The petition must ordinarily be personally served on the debtor in accordance with the applicable procedural requirements.
Where personal service is not possible, it may be necessary to apply for an order permitting alternative service.
The bankruptcy hearing
At the hearing, the court considers whether the statutory requirements have been satisfied and whether a bankruptcy order should be made.
The debtor may oppose the petition, including by disputing the debt or raising other relevant grounds.
The court may make a bankruptcy order, dismiss the petition or adjourn the proceedings.
What happens if the court makes a bankruptcy order?
If a bankruptcy order is made, the debtor's financial affairs become subject to the statutory bankruptcy regime.
An official receiver is initially involved, and a trustee in bankruptcy may subsequently be appointed to investigate the debtor's affairs, identify assets and realise property for the benefit of creditors.
The trustee's powers may extend to the debtor's interest in property, investments and other assets, subject to the applicable statutory provisions and the rights of third parties.
However, obtaining a bankruptcy order does not mean that the petitioning creditor automatically receives payment.
The proceeds of the bankruptcy estate are distributed according to the statutory order of priority, and unsecured creditors may receive only part of their debts or nothing at all.
Is bankruptcy an effective way to recover a debt?
That depends on the debtor's financial circumstances.
A bankruptcy petition may be appropriate where there is reliable evidence of an undisputed debt and the debtor appears unable to pay.
However, the creditor should consider whether the debtor has assets, whether those assets are already subject to security, and whether the likely costs of the proceedings are proportionate to the amount owed.
Bankruptcy is a collective insolvency procedure, not simply a mechanism for enforcing payment to one creditor.
Where the debtor has sufficient assets but refuses to pay, obtaining judgment and pursuing conventional enforcement may be a more appropriate strategy.
What if the debtor disputes the debt?
A creditor should exercise particular caution where the debt is disputed on genuine and substantial grounds.
Bankruptcy proceedings are not intended to replace ordinary civil proceedings for determining contested liabilities.
If the court concludes that the debt is substantially disputed, the petition may be dismissed, potentially with an adverse costs order against the creditor.
A creditor may also face an injunction if insolvency proceedings are threatened or pursued improperly.
We will therefore consider any dispute, counterclaim or set-off before advising whether a bankruptcy petition is appropriate.
How much does it cost to present a bankruptcy petition?
The overall costs depend on the amount and nature of the debt, the documentation available, the debtor's response and whether the petition is contested.
The principal costs ordinarily include:
| Item | Basis of charge |
|---|---|
| Solicitors' fees for preparing and presenting the petition | £750 - £1,250 |
| Court fee | £352 |
| Bankruptcy deposit | £1,500 |
| Process server's fees | £125 - 150 |
| Preparation for and attendance at the hearing | Estimate based on anticipated work |
| Counsel's fees, where instructed | Quotation depending on seniority and complexity |
Additional costs may arise if the debtor opposes the petition, disputes service, seeks an adjournment or raises substantive legal issues.
We will provide a tailored estimate before proceedings are commenced, identifying our professional fees and the anticipated disbursements.
Can the creditor recover the costs?
Certain costs incurred by a petitioning creditor may be payable from the bankruptcy estate in accordance with the applicable insolvency rules and priorities.
However, recovery depends on the available assets and the circumstances of the bankruptcy.
A creditor should not assume that the legal fees, court fee or deposit will necessarily be recovered in full.
If a petition is unsuccessful or improperly pursued, the creditor may also face an adverse costs order.
Can a bankruptcy petition be withdrawn?
Circumstances may change after a petition has been presented.
The debtor may offer payment, negotiate a settlement or propose an alternative arrangement.
However, once a petition has been presented, discontinuing the proceedings is not necessarily as straightforward as withdrawing an ordinary debt claim. The applicable insolvency procedure and the court's involvement must be considered.
Creditors should therefore obtain advice before agreeing settlement terms or taking steps to dispose of a petition.
How Bowman Abraham Solicitors can assist
We advise creditors on all stages of the bankruptcy process, including:
Assessing whether a bankruptcy petition is legally and commercially appropriate.
Preparing the statutory demand
Reviewing the underlying debt and any alleged dispute or counterclaim.
Preparing and presenting bankruptcy petitions.
Arranging service and preparing evidence for hearings.
Instructing counsel and representing creditors in contested proceedings.
Negotiating settlements and considering alternative enforcement options.
Our approach is to assess the prospects of success, the likely financial outcome and the potential costs exposure before recommending proceedings.
Speak to a solicitor
If you are owed a substantial undisputed debt and are considering bankruptcy proceedings, we can advise on the appropriate next steps.
Michael Abraham — Partner
michael.abraham@bowman-abraham.co.uk
Bowman Abraham Solicitors
This article provides general information about the law of England and Wales and does not constitute legal advice on individual circumstances.
