A bankruptcy order can have serious consequences for an individual's finances, property, business interests and family home. However, in certain circumstances, it is possible to apply to the court to have the order annulled.
An annulment is different from being discharged from bankruptcy. Whereas discharge generally releases a bankrupt from many of their debts and restrictions, annulment has the effect of treating the bankruptcy order, subject to certain statutory qualifications, as though it had never been made.
At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we advise individuals facing bankruptcy proceedings and those seeking to challenge or annul bankruptcy orders. We also assist individuals and their families in disputes with trustees in bankruptcy, particularly where the family home is at risk.
When can a bankruptcy order be annulled?
The principal grounds for annulment are contained in section 282 of the Insolvency Act 1986.
There are two principal grounds on which an application may be made:
Under section 282(1)(a), where the bankruptcy order ought not to have been made.
Under section 282(1)(b), where the bankruptcy debts and expenses have been paid or secured to the satisfaction of the court.
There is also provision for annulment following approval of an individual voluntary arrangement (IVA).
1. The bankruptcy order ought not to have been made — section 282(1)(a)
Under section 282(1)(a), the court may annul a bankruptcy order if it is satisfied that, on grounds existing at the time the order was made, the order ought not to have been made.
This may arise in a number of circumstances, including where:
The underlying debt was genuinely disputed on substantial grounds and bankruptcy proceedings should not have been used to determine the dispute.
The debtor had a substantial counterclaim or set-off which should have prevented the bankruptcy order from being made.
The statutory requirements for presenting the bankruptcy petition were not satisfied, including requirements relating to the debt or the debtor's apparent inability to pay.
The debt had already been paid or otherwise discharged before the bankruptcy order was made.
The debtor was not genuinely insolvent and could have discharged the petition debt, but was prevented from doing so because they were unaware of the proceedings or because of another material procedural irregularity.
There were significant procedural irregularities, such as defective service of the petition or a failure to give the debtor a proper opportunity to oppose the proceedings.
There were other substantive grounds which meant that the bankruptcy order ought not to have been made.
Will a procedural error be sufficient to annul a bankruptcy order?
A procedural irregularity will not necessarily justify annulment on its own.
Where a bankruptcy order has been made following a procedural error, such as defective service of the petition, the court will consider whether the irregularity made a material difference to the outcome.
An important consideration is whether the debtor was genuinely insolvent and unable to pay the petition debt, or whether they had the means to discharge it and would have done so had the proceedings been brought to their attention.
For example, where a debtor was not properly served with the bankruptcy petition but can demonstrate that they had sufficient funds or readily available resources to pay the debt, and would have paid it had they been aware of the petition, there may be grounds for annulment.
Similarly, where the debtor can demonstrate that they were not insolvent and that the bankruptcy order resulted from a procedural irregularity which prevented them from taking appropriate steps to avoid it, this may support an application under section 282(1)(a).
Conversely, where the debtor was clearly insolvent, unable to discharge the petition debt and had no substantive grounds for challenging the proceedings, the court may conclude that the bankruptcy order would have been made in any event, notwithstanding the procedural error.
The court will therefore consider not only whether the proceedings were procedurally defective, but also whether the bankruptcy order ought to have been made in light of the debtor's financial circumstances and the steps they could realistically have taken had the irregularity not occurred.
Evidence of the debtor's financial position at the relevant time, including bank statements, available funds, assets and access to finance, may therefore be particularly important in establishing grounds for annulment.
However, the ability to pay is not an absolute requirement for annulment under section 282(1)(a). For example, a genuinely disputed debt or a petition that failed to satisfy the statutory requirements may justify annulment independently of the debtor's wider financial position.
What happens to the underlying debt if the bankruptcy order is annulled under section 282(1)(a)?
An annulment under section 282(1)(a) does not necessarily extinguish the debt upon which the bankruptcy petition was based.
Although the bankruptcy order is annulled, the petitioning creditor may still be entitled to pursue the underlying debt through ordinary civil proceedings, provided that the debt remains legally enforceable.
For example, where a bankruptcy order is annulled because the debt was genuinely disputed on substantial grounds, the creditor may still seek to establish that the debt is owed by bringing a civil claim. The dispute would then be determined through the ordinary litigation process rather than insolvency proceedings.
Similarly, where the bankruptcy order is annulled because of a procedural defect, the underlying debt may remain payable notwithstanding the annulment.
The effect of the annulment on the underlying debt will therefore depend upon the grounds on which the order was annulled and any findings made by the court.
2. Payment in full of the bankruptcy debts and expenses — section 282(1)(b)
A bankruptcy order may also be annulled where the court is satisfied that the bankruptcy debts and expenses have been paid or secured to the court's satisfaction.
Importantly, paying the petitioning creditor alone will not ordinarily be sufficient.
An annulment on this ground will generally require provision for:
All unsecured creditors whose claims are provable in the bankruptcy, including creditors whose debts existed at the date of the bankruptcy order.
Statutory interest on those debts, where applicable.
The petitioning creditor's recoverable costs of presenting the bankruptcy petition.
The Official Receiver's fees and expenses.
The trustee in bankruptcy's properly incurred fees, costs and expenses.
The total sum required can therefore be substantially greater than the debt which originally led to the bankruptcy.
For example, an individual may have been made bankrupt following a petition based on a debt of £20,000, but the total amount required to obtain an annulment could be considerably higher once other creditors' claims, statutory interest and the expenses of the bankruptcy are taken into account.
It is important to obtain a full breakdown of the outstanding liabilities and bankruptcy expenses before determining whether an annulment is financially achievable.
The legislation also permits debts and expenses to be secured to the satisfaction of the court, as an alternative to immediate payment in full. Whether a proposed arrangement is sufficient will depend on the circumstances.
Can the trustee's fees and expenses be challenged?
Where an application is made to annul a bankruptcy order on the basis that the bankruptcy debts and expenses have been paid or secured, the trustee's remuneration and expenses can sometimes become a significant issue.
The fees and expenses claimed by a trustee in bankruptcy are not necessarily beyond challenge. Under rule 10.134 of the Insolvency (England and Wales) Rules 2016, an applicant seeking annulment under section 282(1)(b) of the Insolvency Act 1986 may also apply to challenge the remuneration or expenses of a trustee, other than the Official Receiver, on the grounds that they are excessive in all the circumstances.
Where the court considers the challenge well-founded and annuls the bankruptcy order, it has powers to reduce the trustee's remuneration or make other appropriate orders concerning the disputed fees and expenses.
At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we can review the trustee's claimed remuneration and expenses as part of an annulment application. Where a trustee's remuneration or expenses appear excessive, it may be appropriate to consider a challenge as part of an application to annul the bankruptcy order. This may involve instructing a specialist costs professional to examine the trustee's charges and, where necessary, obtaining advice from specialist insolvency counsel on the merits of a challenge.
Can an annulment be financed using the family home?
In some cases, the bankrupt may have substantial equity in their home but insufficient readily available funds to pay the bankruptcy debts and expenses.
It may be possible to obtain specialist insolvency finance secured against the property to provide the funds needed to facilitate an annulment under section 282(1)(b).
Such arrangements require careful consideration. The property may already be subject to a mortgage, and the bankrupt's beneficial interest may have vested in the trustee in bankruptcy.
Any proposed finance will therefore need to take account of the trustee's position, the available equity, the lender's requirements and the arrangements for completing the annulment.
Specialist finance may provide a route to preserving the home and bringing the bankruptcy to an end, but it will not be suitable or available in every case.
What if annulment is not financially possible?
Annulment is not always the most practical or affordable solution, particularly where the total bankruptcy debts, statutory interest and expenses are substantial.
If the principal concern is to preserve the family home, an alternative may be to negotiate the purchase of the trustee in bankruptcy's beneficial interest in the property.
For example, a spouse, family member or other third party may be able to purchase the trustee's interest for an agreed sum.
The amount payable will depend on the value of the property, the outstanding mortgage and other secured liabilities, the bankrupt's beneficial interest and the trustee's assessment of the available equity.
Purchasing the trustee's interest does not annul the bankruptcy or discharge the underlying debts. However, it may provide a more realistic means of protecting the family home without having to fund payment of all bankruptcy liabilities and expenses.
Where appropriate, we can advise on both options and negotiate with the trustee to seek a commercially sensible outcome.
3. Annulment following an individual voluntary arrangement
A bankruptcy order may also be annulled following approval of an individual voluntary arrangement (IVA), where the applicable statutory requirements are satisfied.
An IVA is a formal arrangement between an individual and their creditors, supervised by an insolvency practitioner.
Depending on the circumstances, an IVA may provide an alternative means of resolving debts and bringing the bankruptcy to an end.
What happens when you apply for annulment?
The procedure depends on the grounds relied upon and the circumstances of the bankruptcy.
An application will ordinarily involve preparing evidence explaining why the bankruptcy order should be annulled.
Depending on the grounds, this may include:
The original bankruptcy petition and supporting documents.
Evidence relating to the disputed debt.
Correspondence with the petitioning creditor.
Evidence of payment or security for debts.
Information concerning the trustee's fees and expenses.
Other documents relevant to the circumstances in which the order was made.
Who must be notified of the annulment application?
Notice of the annulment application must be given to the Official Receiver and, where a trustee in bankruptcy has been appointed, to the trustee.
The application and supporting evidence must be served in accordance with the applicable Insolvency Rules, so that the Official Receiver and trustee have an opportunity to consider the application and make representations to the court.
Depending on the grounds for annulment and the circumstances of the case, notice may also need to be given to the petitioning creditor and other interested parties.
Where the application is contested, the court may hear evidence and legal submissions before deciding whether to annul the bankruptcy order.
What happens to your property during bankruptcy?
When a bankruptcy order is made, certain assets may vest in the trustee in bankruptcy.
These can include the bankrupt's interest in their home, other property, investments and business assets, subject to statutory exceptions.
This can make an annulment application particularly urgent where the trustee is considering selling or otherwise dealing with property.
An application for annulment does not automatically prevent the trustee from taking steps in the bankruptcy.
In appropriate circumstances, it may therefore be necessary to seek an interim order or stay to protect the position pending determination of the application.
What happens if the bankruptcy order is annulled?
The effect of an annulment is that, in legal terms, the individual is generally restored to the position they would have been in had the bankruptcy order never been made.
This is a significant distinction between annulment and discharge from bankruptcy. Whereas discharge brings many of the restrictions and liabilities associated with bankruptcy to an end, annulment effectively sets aside the bankruptcy order itself.
However, there are important qualifications.
Under section 282(4) of the Insolvency Act 1986, certain acts and transactions carried out during the bankruptcy remain valid notwithstanding the annulment. The court may also make appropriate orders concerning property and other matters arising from the bankruptcy.
Accordingly, annulment does not necessarily reverse every transaction undertaken by the Official Receiver or trustee in bankruptcy, particularly where assets have already been sold or third-party rights have arisen.
Removing bankruptcy restrictions from property titles
Where a bankrupt owns or has an interest in property, the bankruptcy may result in entries being made against the property's registered title at HM Land Registry.
These may include bankruptcy notices, bankruptcy restrictions or other restrictions protecting the interests of the trustee in bankruptcy.
Such entries can prevent or complicate a sale, remortgage or other dealing with the property.
Where the bankruptcy order is annulled, it is important to ensure that any bankruptcy-related entries affecting the property are also removed.
When applying for annulment of a bankruptcy order, it is essential to ensure that the proposed court order expressly authorises the cancellation of the relevant bankruptcy registrations at the Land Charges Department, identifying the applicable registration references.
The annulment order will then be required in support of applications to the Land Charges Department and HM Land Registry to remove the bankruptcy notices and restrictions affecting the property's registered title.
These entries are not removed automatically following annulment. Failure to include the necessary provisions in the court order may require a further application to the court before the property's title can be cleared.
Before the annulment hearing, up-to-date official copies of the property's registered title should therefore be obtained so that the relevant entries can be identified and appropriate provisions included in the draft court order.
Where property has vested in the trustee in bankruptcy, the order may also need to address the revesting or disposition of that property. The cancellation of bankruptcy registrations alone may not resolve every issue affecting ownership.
This is particularly important where the annulment is being financed through a mortgage or specialist insolvency loan secured against the property, as the lender will ordinarily require the title to be regularised as part of the transaction.
Publicising the annulment
A bankruptcy order is ordinarily advertised, including through publication in The Gazette.
Following annulment, a request can be made to the Official Receiver or trustee in bankruptcy for notice of the annulment to be advertised, so that creditors and other interested parties are made aware that the bankruptcy order has been annulled.
The arrangements for publication will depend on the circumstances and the applicable procedural requirements.
Removing the bankruptcy from your credit history
A bankruptcy order can have a serious effect on an individual's credit history and ability to obtain borrowing, mortgages or other financial services.
Where a bankruptcy order is annulled, credit reference agencies should remove the bankruptcy entry from the individual's credit file once they have been notified of the annulment and the relevant records have been updated.
It is therefore important to ensure that the annulment is properly recorded and that the principal credit reference agencies are made aware of it.
If the bankruptcy continues to appear on a credit report following annulment, the individual may need to provide a copy of the annulment order and request that the record be corrected.
Annulment does not, however, automatically remove separate adverse credit information, such as defaults or county court judgments relating to underlying debts.
Is there a time limit for applying for annulment?
There is no single 18-day or 21-day deadline for annulment equivalent to the deadlines applicable to challenging a statutory demand.
However, delay can create serious practical difficulties.
For example, the trustee may have incurred substantial expenses, sold assets or taken other steps which cannot easily be reversed.
Where the application is based on the contention that the bankruptcy order should never have been made, prompt action is particularly important.
How much does an annulment application cost?
The costs of applying to annul a bankruptcy order depend on the grounds relied upon, the complexity of the bankruptcy and whether the application is contested.
Our indicative fees for the initial stages are:
| Item | Estimated cost |
|---|---|
| Initial review of the bankruptcy order and advice on the grounds for annulment | £300–£500 |
| Preparing the annulment application and supporting evidence | £1,000–£1,500 |
| Court application fee | £115 |
These estimates exclude VAT where applicable and any additional disbursements.
The above estimate does not include preparation for or attendance at court hearings, or counsel's fees, which will be estimated separately.
Annulment applications sometimes require more than one hearing. For example, proceedings may be adjourned because additional creditors have submitted proofs of debt, disputes have arisen concerning bankruptcy expenses, or arrangements for specialist insolvency finance have been delayed.
Each additional hearing may result in further legal costs.
We will provide a detailed estimate of the anticipated costs once we have reviewed the circumstances of the bankruptcy and identified the appropriate grounds for annulment.
Can legal costs be recovered?
The court has discretion to make costs orders, and recovery is not guaranteed.
An applicant who succeeds in establishing that a bankruptcy order ought not to have been made under section 282(1)(a) may seek an appropriate costs order.
Where annulment is sought under section 282(1)(b), the applicant will ordinarily also need to pay the Official Receiver's or trustee in bankruptcy's fees, costs and expenses, in addition to satisfying the bankruptcy debts and applicable statutory interest.
These expenses can be substantial, particularly where the bankruptcy has been ongoing for some time or the trustee has undertaken significant work in administering the estate. They are separate from our solicitors' fees and the court application fee shown above.
What is the difference between annulment and discharge?
Annulment brings the bankruptcy order to an end on one of the statutory grounds and, subject to the statutory qualifications, treats the bankruptcy as though it had not occurred.
Discharge generally releases an individual from many bankruptcy debts and restrictions, but it does not ordinarily reverse the bankruptcy or restore property that has vested in the trustee.
For someone seeking to protect their home or challenge the original bankruptcy order, the distinction may be particularly significant.
How Bowman Abraham Solicitors can assist
We advise individuals and their families on:
Applications to annul bankruptcy orders under section 282(1)(a) or 282(1)(b).
Assessing whether the original bankruptcy order ought to have been made.
Establishing the sums required to obtain annulment through payment or security.
Reviewing claims by creditors and the fees and expenses of the Official Receiver and trustee.
Negotiating with trustees and creditors.
Exploring arrangements involving specialist insolvency finance.
Negotiating the purchase of a trustee's beneficial interest in the family home.
Urgent applications to protect property pending resolution of a bankruptcy dispute.
Preparing court applications, supporting evidence and representation at contested hearings.
Obtaining orders for the cancellation of bankruptcy notices and restrictions registered against property titles.
Advising on the steps following annulment, including publication of the annulment and correction of bankruptcy entries held by credit reference agencies.
Our approach is to consider not only whether annulment is legally available, but also whether it is the most effective and proportionate way of protecting the client's financial and property interests.
Speak to a solicitor
If you have been made bankrupt and believe that the bankruptcy order should not have been made, or you are considering an application for annulment, early advice is important.
Michael Abraham — Partner
michael.abraham@bowman-abraham.co.uk
Bowman Abraham Solicitors
This article provides general information about the law of England and Wales and does not constitute legal advice on individual circumstances.
