Once the court makes an order placing a company into compulsory liquidation, control of the company's affairs passes to the Official Receiver or an appointed liquidator. The directors generally lose their authority to manage the business, the company's assets become subject to the liquidation process and its trading activities will ordinarily cease.
However, the making of a winding-up order does not necessarily mean that the position is irreversible.
In appropriate circumstances, it may be possible to apply to rescind the winding-up order, appeal against the decision or seek a stay of the winding-up proceedings.
These are distinct legal remedies, with different requirements and consequences.
The appropriate course will depend upon the circumstances in which the order was made, the company's financial position and the time that has elapsed since the order.
In particular, an application to rescind a winding-up order is subject to a very short time limit, making it essential to obtain legal advice promptly.
At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we advise companies and directors facing compulsory liquidation and can assist in assessing the available remedies, preparing urgent applications and arranging specialist insolvency counsel where appropriate.
Can a winding-up order be reversed?
Yes, in certain circumstances.
There are three principal legal routes which may be considered after a winding-up order has been made:
An application to rescind the winding-up order.
An appeal against the order.
An application to stay the winding-up proceedings.
The remedies serve different purposes.
Rescission involves asking the court to set aside its winding-up order.
An appeal involves challenging the decision through the appropriate appellate procedure, usually on the basis that the original decision was wrong or unjust because of a serious procedural or other irregularity.
A stay of winding-up proceedings, by contrast, prevents further steps being taken in the liquidation, either temporarily or permanently, without necessarily setting aside the original winding-up order.
It is important to identify the appropriate remedy at an early stage.
An application made under the wrong procedure may result in delay, additional expense and the loss of an opportunity to obtain effective relief.
What happens when a winding-up order is made?
When a court makes a compulsory winding-up order, the Official Receiver initially becomes the liquidator, subject to the appointment of another liquidator in accordance with the applicable insolvency procedures.
The company enters compulsory liquidation.
The consequences ordinarily include:
The directors losing their powers to manage the company's affairs.
The Official Receiver or liquidator taking control of the company's assets.
The company's bank accounts being frozen or restricted.
The company's business ordinarily ceasing to trade.
The liquidator investigating the company's financial affairs.
Creditors being invited to submit claims in the liquidation.
Company assets being realised for the benefit of creditors.
The liquidator may also investigate transactions entered into before liquidation and the conduct of the directors.
These consequences can arise even where the company believes that the underlying petition debt was disputed or that the winding-up order should not have been made.
The fact that an application for rescission or an appeal is being considered does not automatically suspend the liquidation.
Where urgent protection is required, a separate application for interim relief may need to be considered.
What is an application to rescind a winding-up order?
An application for rescission asks the court that made the winding-up order to reconsider and set aside that order.
The relevant power is contained in rule 12.59 of the Insolvency (England and Wales) Rules 2016.
The rule gives the court jurisdiction to review, rescind or vary orders made in the exercise of its corporate insolvency jurisdiction.
However, rescission is a discretionary remedy.
The court will not automatically set aside a winding-up order merely because the company's directors disagree with the outcome or now wish to defend the petition.
There must be a proper basis for asking the court to reconsider the order.
This may arise where material circumstances were not before the court, where the order was made in the company's absence in circumstances requiring reconsideration, or where there is another substantial reason why the order should not stand.
The court will consider the evidence, the explanation for the circumstances giving rise to the order and the interests of creditors.
What is the time limit for applying to rescind a winding-up order?
An application to rescind a winding-up order must ordinarily be made within five business days after the date on which the order was made.
This time limit is imposed by rule 12.59(3) of the Insolvency (England and Wales) Rules 2016.
It is a particularly short period, and directors should seek advice immediately upon discovering that a winding-up order has been made.
Can you apply after the five-business-day deadline?
Potentially, yes.
The court has power to extend time, but an extension is not automatic.
Where an application is made outside the prescribed period, it should include an application for an extension of time and evidence explaining the delay.
The court will consider the circumstances, including the reason for the late application and the merits of the proposed rescission.
For example, a company may only have discovered that the order was made after the expiry of the five-business-day period.
That may be relevant, but it does not guarantee that an extension will be granted.
The longer the delay, the greater the potential complications, particularly if the Official Receiver or liquidator has already taken steps in administering the company's affairs.
Who can apply to rescind a winding-up order?
The Insolvency Practice Direction contains specific requirements concerning who may apply for rescission.
An application may be made by a creditor or a contributory, which ordinarily includes a shareholder.
The company may also apply jointly with a creditor or contributory.
Accordingly, directors should not assume that they can simply make an application in the company's name without considering the applicable requirements.
Where the directors are also shareholders, the appropriate basis for bringing the application may need to be considered.
The application must be supported by witness statement evidence and appropriate information concerning the company's assets and liabilities.
Notice must also be given to the relevant parties, including the petitioning creditor, supporting or opposing creditors, the Official Receiver and any appointed insolvency practitioner, as applicable.
At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we can advise on the correct procedure and ensure that the application is brought by the appropriate parties.
On what grounds can a winding-up order be rescinded?
The appropriate grounds will depend upon the circumstances.
There are several situations in which rescission may be considered.
1. The winding-up order was made in the company's absence
A company may discover that a winding-up order was made at a hearing which its directors did not attend.
This may have occurred because the company was unaware of the hearing, misunderstood the proceedings or failed to respond to the petition.
However, the mere fact that the company did not attend does not automatically justify rescission.
The court will consider why the company was absent and whether there is a substantive basis for reconsidering the order.
For example, the company may have evidence demonstrating that the debt was genuinely disputed or that it had a substantial cross-claim against the petitioning creditor.
Where the company can establish both a proper explanation for its absence and a substantial basis for challenging the petition, there may be grounds for rescission.
2. The petition was not properly served
A winding-up petition must be served in accordance with the applicable insolvency rules.
Where there has been a material failure to comply with the service requirements, this may provide grounds for challenging the resulting order.
For example, the company may contend that the petition was not properly served and that it was consequently deprived of a fair opportunity to respond.
The court will consider the nature of the defect, whether the company had actual notice of the proceedings and whether the irregularity materially affected the fairness of the hearing.
Not every procedural defect will justify rescission.
The circumstances must be examined carefully.
3. The underlying debt was genuinely disputed
A winding-up petition should not ordinarily be used to enforce a debt genuinely disputed on substantial grounds.
Where a winding-up order has been made despite the existence of a genuine and substantial dispute, this may provide a basis for seeking to challenge the order.
For example, the company may have a substantial contractual defence arising from defective goods, defective services, breach of contract or an incorrect calculation of the amount claimed.
Alternatively, the company may have a genuine and substantial cross-claim against the petitioning creditor.
However, the existence of a defence which could have been raised before the original hearing does not automatically justify rescission.
The court will consider why the relevant matters were not advanced previously and whether there is a proper basis for reopening the decision.
4. Material information was not before the court
Rescission may also be considered where significant information was not placed before the court when the winding-up order was made.
For example, there may have been a material development concerning payment, settlement or the company's financial position which the court was not informed about.
The significance of the information will depend upon the circumstances.
The court will consider whether the information could have affected the decision to make the winding-up order and why it was not presented at the original hearing.
5. The debt was paid or settled
Where the petition debt was paid or settled before the winding-up order was made, but the court was not informed, this may provide grounds for reconsidering the order.
However, payment after the winding-up order has been made is a different matter.
At that stage, the liquidation has already commenced, and the interests of creditors generally must be considered.
Payment of the original petitioning creditor does not necessarily justify rescission.
The appropriate remedy may instead involve an application to stay the winding up, depending on the company's wider financial position.
Can a winding-up order be rescinded if the company is solvent?
Evidence that the company is solvent may be relevant to an application for rescission.
However, solvency does not automatically entitle the company to have the order set aside.
The court will consider the basis upon which the winding-up order was originally made and the grounds relied upon for rescission.
A company may own substantial assets but nevertheless be unable to pay its debts as they fall due.
Conversely, evidence that the company was able to discharge its liabilities, or that the original petition was not properly founded, may be relevant to the court's assessment.
It will ordinarily be important to provide reliable financial evidence.
This may include management accounts, bank statements, asset valuations and a schedule of creditors.
Where the company has substantial assets but requires time to realise them, the appropriate remedy will depend upon the circumstances and the stage of the liquidation.
What evidence is needed for an application to rescind a winding-up order?
An application for rescission must be supported by witness statement evidence.
The evidence should explain why the winding-up order was made, why it should be rescinded and the company's financial position.
Depending on the circumstances, relevant documents may include:
The winding-up petition and supporting documents.
The winding-up order.
Evidence concerning service of the petition.
Correspondence with the petitioning creditor.
Documents supporting any defence to the debt.
Evidence of any substantial cross-claim.
Proof of payment or settlement, where relevant.
Recent company accounts and management accounts.
Bank statements.
A schedule of assets and liabilities.
Details of other creditors.
Evidence explaining any failure to attend the hearing.
An explanation for any delay in applying.
The Insolvency Practice Direction specifically requires the supporting witness statement to include details of the company's assets and liabilities.
Where the application is made outside the five-business-day period, the evidence should also explain the delay.
The court will require a clear and credible explanation of the circumstances.
It is therefore important to prepare the evidence carefully and address the relevant legal requirements rather than simply request that the company be restored to its previous position.
Can you appeal against a winding-up order?
Yes.
An appeal may be appropriate where the company contends that the court made an error of law, reached a decision that was wrong or conducted the proceedings in a manner involving a serious procedural or other irregularity.
Appeals are governed by the applicable insolvency provisions and CPR Part 52.
An appeal is different from an application for rescission.
An appeal ordinarily focuses on whether the original decision was legally or procedurally wrong, rather than simply asking the same court to reconsider the matter in light of circumstances not previously advanced.
Permission to appeal will generally be required.
The applicable test ordinarily includes whether the proposed appeal has a real prospect of success or whether there is some other compelling reason for the appeal to be heard.
What is the time limit for appealing a winding-up order?
The ordinary time limit for filing an appellant's notice is 21 days after the decision, unless the court has directed a different period or another applicable rule provides otherwise.
It is important not to confuse this with the five-business-day period for applying for rescission.
The appropriate deadline and route of appeal must be established by reference to the court that made the order and the circumstances of the decision.
Where the appeal period has expired, an extension of time may be required.
An appeal does not automatically stay the winding-up order.
Accordingly, urgent consideration may need to be given to whether a separate stay or other interim relief should be sought pending determination of the appeal.
What is a stay of winding-up proceedings?
A stay of winding-up proceedings is a different remedy from rescission.
Under section 147 of the Insolvency Act 1986, the court has power to stay winding-up proceedings, either altogether or for a limited period, on such terms and conditions as it considers appropriate.
An application may be made by the liquidator, Official Receiver, creditor or contributory.
The court must be satisfied that the winding-up proceedings ought to be stayed.
What is the difference between a permanent stay and rescission?
Rescission sets aside the winding-up order.
A permanent stay, by contrast, brings the winding-up proceedings to a halt without necessarily removing the winding-up order itself.
This distinction is important because a stay does not automatically restore the company's affairs to the position they were in before liquidation.
The consequences for the company, its directors, creditors and the liquidator must be considered.
The court may also impose conditions when granting a stay.
Where the objective is to enable the company to resume business, the practical and legal consequences of the proposed order should be examined carefully.
Can you obtain a permanent stay by paying all the company's debts?
Potentially, yes.
Where the company's debts and the expenses of the liquidation can be paid or adequately secured, an application for a permanent stay may be appropriate.
However, the position is not necessarily resolved simply by paying the original petitioning creditor.
Once a winding-up order has been made, the liquidation concerns the interests of creditors generally.
The court will therefore need to consider the wider position, including other creditors and the expenses incurred in the liquidation.
These may include:
The petitioning creditor's outstanding debt and recoverable costs.
Other creditors' claims.
The Official Receiver's fees and expenses.
The liquidator's remuneration and expenses.
Other properly incurred expenses of the liquidation.
The court may also consider the company's financial position and the circumstances in which the winding-up order was made.
Where all creditors and the liquidation expenses can be satisfactorily addressed, there may be a basis for seeking a permanent stay.
However, the court retains discretion and will consider the circumstances of the case.
Can you obtain a temporary stay of winding-up proceedings?
Yes, in appropriate circumstances.
Section 147 permits the court to stay winding-up proceedings for a limited period.
A temporary stay may be relevant where there is a proper basis for suspending further liquidation activity while a particular issue is addressed.
For example, it may be necessary to seek interim protection while an appeal or another application is being considered.
However, the court will require sufficient justification for the proposed stay.
The interests of creditors and the potential consequences of delaying the liquidation will be important considerations.
The fact that the directors wish to continue operating the company will not, by itself, justify a stay.
What happens to the Official Receiver's and liquidator's costs?
The costs and expenses incurred following a winding-up order can be significant.
Once the Official Receiver or liquidator has commenced administering the company's affairs, costs may be incurred in investigating its financial position, dealing with creditors and taking control of its assets.
Where the company seeks rescission or a permanent stay, those costs may need to be addressed.
The position will depend upon the remedy sought, the circumstances of the order and the court's directions.
In particular, where a permanent stay is sought on the basis that the company's liabilities can be discharged, the expenses of the liquidation will ordinarily require careful consideration.
Where the amount claimed by a liquidator is disputed, it may be appropriate to obtain specialist advice concerning the applicable remuneration and expenses.
However, the existence of a dispute about liquidation costs does not automatically entitle the company to rescission or a stay.
Can the company resume trading if the winding-up order is rescinded?
Potentially, yes.
Where a winding-up order is rescinded, the company may be able to resume normal management and trading activities.
However, the practical consequences will depend upon the terms of the court order and what has occurred during the liquidation.
For example, the Official Receiver or liquidator may already have taken control of assets, dealt with company records or entered into transactions.
The company's bank may also require formal confirmation of the court's order before restoring access to its accounts.
It may be necessary to notify Companies House, the bank and other relevant parties.
Where assets have been realised or third-party rights have arisen, the position may be more complicated.
It is therefore important to consider not only whether rescission can be obtained but also the practical steps required afterwards.
What if the winding-up order was made without the directors knowing?
This situation requires urgent investigation.
The first step is to establish how the petition was served, when the hearing took place and what information was before the court.
The company should obtain copies of the petition, the evidence of service and the winding-up order.
It will then be necessary to consider whether there were procedural irregularities and whether the company had a substantive basis for opposing the petition.
For example, the company may contend that it never received the petition and had no opportunity to explain that the debt was genuinely disputed.
However, a lack of actual knowledge does not necessarily establish defective service.
The court will consider whether the applicable service requirements were satisfied.
Where there are grounds for challenging the order, an urgent application for rescission or an appeal may be appropriate.
The five-business-day time limit for rescission makes prompt action particularly important.
Can a director personally apply to reverse the winding-up order?
A director's position must be distinguished from that of the company, its creditors and its shareholders.
Being a director does not, by itself, necessarily confer standing to make every application available in the liquidation.
For rescission, the Insolvency Practice Direction identifies creditors, contributories and applications made by the company jointly with a creditor or contributory.
A director who is also a shareholder may have standing as a contributory, depending on the circumstances.
Similarly, section 147 identifies the parties entitled to apply for a stay.
The correct applicant and procedure should therefore be established before proceedings are commenced.
This can be particularly important where the company's directors have lost their management powers following the winding-up order.
Should specialist insolvency counsel be instructed?
Applications to rescind winding-up orders, appeals and applications for permanent stays can involve complex issues of insolvency law and procedure.
Given the consequences of compulsory liquidation and the short time limits involved, it will often be advisable to obtain advice from specialist insolvency counsel.
At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we work closely with experienced barristers specialising in insolvency law.
Where appropriate, we can arrange for counsel to advise on the merits of the proposed application and represent the applicant at court.
Counsel's involvement may be particularly valuable where the winding-up order was made in disputed circumstances, the application is opposed or there are complex issues concerning the company's solvency and creditors.
We can also coordinate the preparation of the necessary witness statement evidence and financial information.
Where the prospects of rescission are limited, we can consider whether an appeal, an application for a stay or another practical resolution may be more appropriate.
How much does it cost to rescind a winding-up order?
The legal costs will depend on the circumstances in which the order was made, the remedy sought and whether the application is contested.
An urgent rescission application made shortly after the winding-up order may involve different work from an application for a permanent stay where the liquidation has been ongoing for some time.
Our work may include:
Reviewing the winding-up order and underlying petition.
Investigating the circumstances in which the order was made.
Advising on rescission, appeal and stay procedures.
Assessing the company's financial position.
Reviewing the claims of creditors.
Preparing witness statements and supporting evidence.
Applying for an extension of time where necessary.
Corresponding with the Official Receiver or liquidator.
Instructing specialist insolvency counsel.
Preparing for and attending court hearings.
Advising on the practical steps following a successful application.
We will provide an estimate of our fees after reviewing the circumstances.
Court fees and counsel's fees will generally be additional disbursements.
There may also be an adverse costs risk where an application is unsuccessful.
In particular, the Insolvency Practice Direction provides that an unsuccessful rescission applicant will normally be ordered to pay the costs of relevant creditors, the Official Receiver and any appointed insolvency practitioner.
How Bowman Abraham Solicitors can assist
At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we advise companies and directors facing compulsory liquidation and assist with applications arising from winding-up orders.
Our experience in commercial litigation, contractual disputes and contentious insolvency enables us to consider both the underlying debt dispute and the available insolvency remedies.
We can assist with:
Applications to rescind winding-up orders.
Urgent applications following orders made in the company's absence.
Investigating defective service and procedural irregularities.
Challenging winding-up orders based on genuinely disputed debts.
Advising on appeals against winding-up orders.
Applications for temporary or permanent stays under section 147 of the Insolvency Act 1986.
Negotiating with creditors and liquidators.
Reviewing liquidation costs and expenses.
Preparing evidence concerning the company's assets, liabilities and financial position.
Instructing specialist insolvency counsel where appropriate.
Our objective is to identify the most effective available remedy and, wherever reasonably possible, protect the company's assets and commercial interests.
Urgent legal advice on rescinding a winding-up order
If a winding-up order has been made against your company, it is important to obtain legal advice immediately.
An application for rescission must ordinarily be made within five business days of the order.
Although an extension of time may be available, delay can make the position more difficult, particularly where the Official Receiver or liquidator has already commenced administering the company's affairs.
Depending on the circumstances, it may be possible to apply for rescission, pursue an appeal or seek a stay of the winding-up proceedings.
Bowman Abraham Solicitors can assess the available options, prepare the necessary application and arrange specialist insolvency counsel where appropriate.
Michael Abraham — Partner
michael.abraham@bowman-abraham.co.uk
Bowman Abraham Solicitors
This article provides general information about the law of England and Wales and does not constitute legal advice on individual circumstances.
