Where a creditor presents a petition seeking the compulsory liquidation of a company, the consequences can be severe. The company's banking arrangements may be disrupted, its commercial reputation damaged and its ability to continue trading placed at risk.
However, the presentation of a winding-up petition does not mean that the company will inevitably be wound up.
There are several grounds upon which a petition may be challenged, including where the debt is genuinely disputed, the company has a substantial cross-claim against the creditor, or the petition is being used improperly as a means of debt collection.
Even where the debt is admitted, it may be possible to negotiate a settlement or obtain an adjournment to allow time for payment.
The key is to act promptly, particularly before the petition is advertised in The Gazette.
At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we advise companies and directors facing winding-up petitions, including challenging disputed debts, negotiating settlements, seeking injunctions and defending proceedings before the Insolvency and Companies Court.
What is a winding-up petition?
A winding-up petition is a formal application to the court seeking an order that a company be placed into compulsory liquidation.
A creditor will commonly present a petition on the basis that the company is unable to pay its debts within the meaning of section 123 of the Insolvency Act 1986.
If the court makes a winding-up order, a liquidator will take control of the company's affairs, its assets will be dealt with for the benefit of creditors and its business will ordinarily cease trading.
The directors' powers will generally come to an end, although directors will remain subject to duties to cooperate with the liquidator and provide information concerning the company's affairs.
A winding-up petition is therefore fundamentally different from an ordinary claim for payment of a debt.
It is a collective insolvency procedure with potentially far-reaching consequences for the company and its creditors.
On what grounds can a winding-up petition be defended?
There are several possible grounds for opposing a winding-up petition.
These include:
The debt relied upon by the creditor is genuinely disputed on substantial grounds.
The company has a genuine and substantial cross-claim against the creditor.
The debt has been paid or otherwise properly settled.
The creditor has no standing to present the petition.
The petition is procedurally defective.
The company is able to pay its debts and there is insufficient justification for making a winding-up order.
The court should exercise its discretion to dismiss or adjourn the petition.
The appropriate defence will depend upon the particular circumstances.
In some cases, the correct approach will be to oppose the petition outright. In others, it may be preferable to negotiate with the creditor or seek an adjournment to allow the company to discharge the debt.
Can a winding-up petition be defended if the debt is disputed?
Yes. This is one of the most important grounds for opposing a winding-up petition.
The courts have repeatedly confirmed that winding-up proceedings should not ordinarily be used to enforce a debt that is genuinely disputed on substantial grounds.
A creditor should not use the threat of compulsory liquidation to pressure a company into paying a debt where there is a genuine dispute that ought properly to be determined through ordinary civil proceedings.
For example, a company may dispute liability because:
The goods or services supplied were defective.
The creditor failed to perform its contractual obligations.
The amount invoiced is incorrect.
The creditor has charged for work that was not authorised.
There has been a breach of contract.
The company has already made payment.
The debt is not yet due or is otherwise unenforceable.
The mere assertion that a debt is disputed will not be sufficient.
The company must demonstrate that the dispute is genuine and has sufficient substance to justify determination through ordinary litigation.
However, the company is not ordinarily required to establish conclusively at the petition hearing that its defence will succeed.
The winding-up court is not the appropriate forum for conducting a full trial of a substantial commercial dispute.
What does the court mean by a debt disputed on substantial grounds?
The court will examine whether there is a genuine issue requiring determination, rather than an artificial or unsupported attempt to avoid payment.
Evidence may include contracts, invoices, correspondence, contemporaneous complaints, expert reports or other documentation supporting the company's position.
The relevant principles have been considered in a number of cases, including Tallington Lakes Ltd v South Kesteven District Council [2012] EWCA Civ 443 and Mulalley & Co Ltd v Regent Building Services Ltd [2017] EWHC 2962 (Ch).
The courts have emphasised that the threshold for establishing a substantial dispute is not particularly high, although the company must still provide a credible evidential basis for its defence.
Where the debt is genuinely disputed on substantial grounds, the creditor should ordinarily pursue its claim through conventional civil proceedings rather than insolvency proceedings.
What if the company has a cross-claim against the creditor?
A company may also be able to oppose a winding-up petition where it has a genuine and substantial cross-claim against the petitioning creditor.
This can arise even where the company accepts that an amount is otherwise due.
For example, a contractor may be owed payment for completed work, but the company may have a substantial claim against the contractor for defective workmanship, delay or breach of contract.
Alternatively, a supplier may be owed money for goods supplied, but the company may have suffered losses arising from defective goods or other contractual breaches.
Where the company's cross-claim equals or exceeds the petition debt and is genuine and substantial, the court will ordinarily be reluctant to permit the creditor to use winding-up proceedings, subject to exceptional circumstances.
The legal position will depend upon the nature of the cross-claim and whether it gives rise to a set-off or otherwise provides a proper basis for opposing the petition.
The company must be able to provide evidence demonstrating that the cross-claim has substance.
A speculative claim or an unsupported allegation of loss will not ordinarily be sufficient.
Importantly, the existence of a cross-claim may provide a defence to the petition even though the company has not yet commenced separate proceedings to pursue that claim.
At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, our experience in commercial and contractual disputes enables us to consider not only the insolvency proceedings themselves but also the underlying contractual relationship and any claims available to the company.
Can a creditor use a winding-up petition to force payment of a disputed debt?
A winding-up petition should not be used as an improper means of exerting commercial pressure.
Where a debt is genuinely disputed on substantial grounds, presenting or pursuing a winding-up petition may amount to an abuse of the court's process.
The principle is particularly important because the consequences of a winding-up petition can be disproportionate to the amount of the alleged debt.
The threat of advertisement, banking restrictions and reputational damage may place substantial pressure on a company to make payment even where it has a legitimate defence.
In appropriate circumstances, the company may apply to the court for an injunction restraining the creditor from presenting or advertising the petition.
The court may also dismiss a petition that has already been presented.
Where a petition has been improperly pursued, the company may seek an order requiring the creditor to pay its legal costs.
Why is it important to act before the winding-up petition is advertised?
The advertisement of a winding-up petition is often a critical stage in the proceedings.
A petition is ordinarily advertised in The Gazette, making the proceedings publicly known.
Under rule 7.10 of the Insolvency (England and Wales) Rules 2016, where a creditor presents the petition, advertisement must generally take place at least seven business days after service of the petition on the company and at least seven business days before the hearing, unless the court directs otherwise.
Once advertised, the petition may come to the attention of banks, suppliers, customers and other creditors.
The consequences can be immediate and serious.
What happens to the company's bank account?
Banks may freeze or restrict a company's accounts after becoming aware that a winding-up petition has been presented.
This is principally because of the potential effect of section 127 of the Insolvency Act 1986.
Where a winding-up order is subsequently made, dispositions of the company's property after the commencement of the winding up are generally void unless the court orders otherwise.
For these purposes, the commencement of a compulsory winding up ordinarily relates back to the date of presentation of the petition.
Banks may therefore be concerned that payments made from the company's accounts could subsequently be challenged.
The resulting restrictions can make it extremely difficult for a company to pay employees, suppliers and other essential expenses.
Can advertisement be prevented?
Yes, in appropriate circumstances.
Where a winding-up petition is based on a debt genuinely disputed on substantial grounds, or where there is another proper basis for challenging the proceedings, the company may apply for an injunction restraining advertisement.
Such applications are often urgent because the objective is to prevent the commercial damage associated with publication.
The company will need to place appropriate evidence before the court demonstrating why the petition should not be advertised.
Where necessary, an urgent application may be made before the scheduled petition hearing.
At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we can assess whether there are grounds for seeking an injunction and arrange specialist insolvency counsel to advise and represent the company where appropriate.
What if the winding-up petition has already been advertised?
The fact that a petition has already been advertised does not mean that it cannot be defended.
The company may still oppose the petition, seek its dismissal or negotiate a settlement.
However, the position may become more complicated.
Other creditors may become aware of the proceedings and seek to support the petition.
The company may also encounter difficulties with its bank accounts and commercial relationships.
Depending on the circumstances, it may be necessary to consider an application for a validation order to enable essential payments to continue.
Urgent steps may also be required to deal with the hearing and ensure that the company's opposition is properly presented.
The earlier the company obtains legal advice, the greater the opportunity to address these difficulties before they escalate.
What is a validation order?
A validation order is a court order permitting or validating specified transactions notwithstanding the restrictions arising under section 127 of the Insolvency Act 1986.
Where a winding-up petition has been presented, the company may experience difficulties making payments or dealing with its assets.
A validation order can provide protection for particular transactions if the court considers it appropriate.
For example, an application may concern:
Payment of employees' wages.
Essential trading expenses.
Payments to suppliers necessary to maintain business operations.
Transactions required to preserve the value of the company's business.
Other specified dealings with company assets.
The court will consider the company's financial circumstances, the proposed transactions and whether granting the order is consistent with the interests of creditors.
A validation order is not automatic.
The company will ordinarily need to provide detailed financial evidence explaining why the transactions should be permitted.
It is important that directors do not assume that ordinary business payments are necessarily protected simply because they are made in the course of trading.
Can a winding-up petition be stopped by paying the debt?
In many cases, yes.
Where the company accepts that the petition debt is due and has the funds available, payment may provide a means of resolving the proceedings.
However, payment does not automatically bring the petition to an end.
The company must also consider the petitioning creditor's legal costs, the procedural requirements for disposing of the petition and whether other creditors have become involved.
A creditor may agree to seek permission to withdraw the petition or to an order dismissing it once payment has been made.
The appropriate procedure will depend upon the circumstances.
Is it safe to pay the petitioning creditor after the petition has been presented?
Particular care is required where the company proposes to make payment from its own assets after presentation of the petition.
Under section 127 of the Insolvency Act 1986, dispositions of company property made after commencement of the winding up may be void if a winding-up order is subsequently made, unless the court orders otherwise.
Accordingly, payment of the petitioning creditor does not necessarily eliminate every legal risk.
This is particularly relevant where other creditors may seek to continue the proceedings.
Depending on the circumstances, it may be appropriate to consider a validation order or arrangements involving funds provided by a third party.
The source of payment, the terms of settlement and the steps required to dispose of the petition should be considered carefully before money is transferred.
Can you negotiate a settlement of a winding-up petition?
Yes.
Where the debt is admitted or there is a commercial basis for compromise, it may be possible to negotiate a settlement with the petitioning creditor.
This may involve payment of the outstanding debt, an agreed reduced amount or a structured payment arrangement.
The creditor may be willing to settle rather than incur further costs pursuing insolvency proceedings.
However, the creditor is not obliged to accept a reduced payment or instalments.
Any settlement should be documented carefully and should address:
The amount payable.
The timing and source of payment.
The treatment of interest and legal costs.
Whether the settlement is in full and final satisfaction of the relevant liability.
The creditor's obligations concerning the petition.
The position if another creditor seeks to continue the proceedings.
It is important to distinguish between reaching a settlement with the original petitioning creditor and ensuring that the winding-up proceedings have been formally brought to an end.
Can a winding-up petition be adjourned to allow more time to pay?
Yes.
Where a company is unable to discharge the petition debt immediately but expects to be able to do so within a reasonable period, it may be possible to obtain an adjournment.
The court has discretion to adjourn a winding-up petition where there are sufficient grounds.
This can be particularly important where the company is awaiting refinancing, payment of a substantial outstanding invoice, completion of an asset sale or the injection of additional capital.
The court will ordinarily expect credible evidence demonstrating that payment is realistically achievable.
For example, relevant evidence might include:
Confirmation of funding arrangements.
Evidence of an agreed sale of an asset.
Documentation concerning anticipated investment.
Evidence of substantial sums due to the company.
A clear and realistic timetable for payment.
Financial information explaining the company's present and anticipated position.
How long can a winding-up petition be adjourned for?
There is no fixed rule governing the period of an adjournment.
The length of time allowed will depend on the circumstances, the evidence available and the interests of creditors.
A period of approximately three months may be a reasonable period to seek where there is credible evidence that the company will be able to discharge the debt within that time.
However, the court is not obliged to grant such a period and may allow a shorter adjournment, impose conditions or refuse the application.
In particular, the court will consider whether there is a realistic prospect of payment rather than a speculative hope that funds may eventually become available.
At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we can assist in preparing the evidence and making representations to support an application for additional time.
Can a winding-up petition be dismissed if the company is solvent?
Potentially, yes, although the position requires careful consideration.
A company may own substantial assets yet still experience serious cash-flow difficulties.
Under section 123 of the Insolvency Act 1986, a company's inability to pay its debts may be established in a number of ways, including an inability to meet debts as they fall due.
The fact that the company owns assets worth more than its liabilities does not necessarily mean that it can defeat a winding-up petition.
For example, a company may own valuable property but have insufficient available funds to pay an undisputed debt that has fallen due.
Conversely, evidence that the company is able to meet its liabilities, together with other relevant circumstances, may support an argument that a winding-up order should not be made.
The court will consider the statutory grounds for winding up and the evidence concerning the company's financial position.
Where the company has substantial assets but requires time to realise them, an application for an adjournment may be more appropriate than simply asserting that the company is solvent.
Can another creditor take over the winding-up petition?
Potentially, yes.
Winding-up proceedings are collective in nature and are not solely concerned with the interests of the original petitioning creditor.
Where the original creditor has been paid or no longer wishes to pursue the petition, another qualifying creditor may, in appropriate circumstances, seek to be substituted as petitioner.
This means that paying the original petitioning creditor does not invariably guarantee that the proceedings will come to an end.
The position is particularly important where the petition has already been advertised and other creditors have become aware of the company's financial difficulties.
Before concluding a settlement, the company should therefore establish whether any other creditors have indicated an intention to support the petition.
What happens at the winding-up petition hearing?
At the hearing, the court will consider whether the statutory grounds for winding up have been established and whether a winding-up order should be made.
Depending on the circumstances, the court may:
Make a winding-up order.
Dismiss the petition.
Adjourn the hearing.
Make directions for the further conduct of the proceedings.
Deal with costs and other appropriate matters.
Where the company opposes the petition, it will ordinarily be necessary to prepare and file evidence explaining the grounds of opposition.
The applicable procedural requirements and any directions made by the court must be followed.
In a case involving a substantial dispute, the company may contend that the petition should be dismissed because the creditor's claim ought to be pursued through ordinary civil proceedings.
Where the company accepts the debt but requires additional time, the focus may instead be on demonstrating a credible and properly evidenced proposal for payment.
Specialist insolvency counsel may be appropriate, particularly where the petition is contested or complex issues arise.
What happens if the court makes a winding-up order?
If the court makes a compulsory winding-up order, the Official Receiver will initially become liquidator, subject to the appointment of another liquidator in accordance with the applicable insolvency procedures.
The company's assets will be administered for the benefit of creditors.
The directors will generally lose control over the company's affairs, and the company will ordinarily cease trading.
The liquidator may investigate the company's transactions, financial affairs and the conduct of its directors.
There may also be consequences for contracts, employees, suppliers and other commercial relationships.
Although there are procedures by which a winding-up order may be challenged or, in appropriate circumstances, rescinded, these are not a substitute for taking timely steps to oppose the petition before an order is made.
Preventing an inappropriate winding-up order is generally preferable to attempting to reverse its consequences afterwards.
What should company directors do when a winding-up petition is received?
Directors should act promptly and take the proceedings seriously.
The immediate priority should be to establish the basis of the petition, the amount claimed, the hearing date and whether advertisement is imminent.
The company should also assess whether the debt is disputed, whether there is a cross-claim, and whether payment or settlement is realistically achievable.
It is important to preserve relevant financial and contractual documents.
Directors should also be mindful of their duties where the company is insolvent or approaching insolvency, including the need to consider creditors' interests.
Transactions involving company assets should be approached carefully, particularly after presentation of a petition.
Where there are grounds for challenging the petition, urgent legal advice may be necessary to prevent advertisement or prepare the company's opposition.
How much does it cost to defend a winding-up petition?
The costs will depend on the complexity of the matter, the grounds of opposition and the stage at which solicitors are instructed.
Some petitions can be resolved through correspondence and negotiation.
Others require urgent injunction proceedings, substantial witness evidence or representation at a contested hearing.
Our work may include:
Reviewing the petition and supporting documents.
Assessing whether the debt is genuinely disputed.
Advising on contractual claims, cross-claims and set-offs.
Corresponding with the petitioning creditor's solicitors.
Negotiating settlement or payment arrangements.
Preparing applications to restrain advertisement.
Advising on validation orders.
Preparing evidence in opposition to the petition.
Seeking adjournments to allow time for payment.
Arranging representation at court.
Seeking appropriate costs orders.
We will provide an estimate of our fees after reviewing the circumstances of the case.
Where specialist counsel is required, we can explain the likely additional fees before instructions are given.
How Bowman Abraham Solicitors can assist
At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we advise companies facing winding-up petitions and assist directors in responding to urgent insolvency proceedings.
Our experience in commercial litigation, contractual disputes, debt recovery and contentious insolvency enables us to consider both the winding-up proceedings and the underlying commercial dispute.
We can assist with:
Defending winding-up petitions based on genuinely disputed debts.
Advancing substantial cross-claims and set-offs.
Seeking injunctions to prevent the presentation or advertisement of petitions.
Negotiating settlements with petitioning creditors.
Seeking adjournments where payment can realistically be arranged.
Advising on validation orders and restrictions affecting company assets.
Preparing evidence and representing companies in contested proceedings.
Instructing specialist insolvency counsel where appropriate.
We work closely with barristers specialising in insolvency law and can arrange specialist advice and representation where the circumstances require it.
Our objective is to identify the strongest available legal and commercial response, protect the company's position and, wherever reasonably possible, prevent a winding-up order from being made.
Speak to a solicitor about defending a winding-up petition
If your company has received a winding-up petition, or a creditor is threatening to present one, it is important to obtain advice without delay.
Where the debt is genuinely disputed, there may be grounds to prevent the petition from proceeding.
Where payment is possible, settlement or an adjournment may provide an alternative means of avoiding compulsory liquidation.
However, the consequences of advertisement and the restrictions affecting company assets mean that early action can be critical.
Bowman Abraham Solicitors can assess the company's position, advise on the available options and take appropriate steps to challenge or resolve the proceedings.
Michael Abraham — Partner
michael.abraham@bowman-abraham.co.uk
Bowman Abraham Solicitors
This article provides general information about the law of England and Wales and does not constitute legal advice on individual circumstances.
