← Corporate Insolvency & Winding-Up

Validation Orders: How to Keep Your Company Trading After a Winding-Up Petition

The presentation of a winding-up petition can cause immediate and serious difficulties for a company, particularly where its bank becomes aware of the proceedings and freezes or restricts its accounts.

Even where the company has sufficient funds to meet its immediate trading expenses, it may find itself unable to pay employees, suppliers, rent or other essential business costs.

For a trading company, the consequences can be severe. The inability to make ordinary business payments may disrupt operations, damage commercial relationships and threaten the company's continued existence.

However, it may be possible to obtain a validation order from the court permitting specified transactions to take place notwithstanding the presentation of the winding-up petition.

A validation order can allow a company to continue making essential payments, protect particular transactions and, in appropriate circumstances, enable the business to continue trading while the winding-up proceedings remain unresolved.

The court will not grant such an order automatically. It will need to be satisfied that there is a proper basis for validating the proposed transactions, taking account of the company's financial position and the interests of creditors.

At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we advise companies and directors facing winding-up proceedings and can assist with applications for validation orders, including urgent applications where access to company funds is required.

What is a validation order?

A validation order is an order made by the court under section 127 of the Insolvency Act 1986 permitting or validating transactions involving a company's property after the commencement of a compulsory winding up.

Section 127 provides that, in a winding up by the court, dispositions of the company's property made after the commencement of the winding up are void unless the court otherwise orders.

The significance of this provision is that, under section 129 of the Insolvency Act 1986, the commencement of a compulsory winding up ordinarily relates back to the date on which the winding-up petition was presented.

Consequently, where a winding-up order is subsequently made, payments and other transactions involving company property after presentation of the petition may be treated as void unless validated by the court.

A validation order provides protection against that consequence for transactions covered by the order.

It may authorise future transactions or retrospectively validate transactions which have already taken place.

However, a validation order does not dismiss the winding-up petition, determine the underlying debt dispute or guarantee that the company will avoid liquidation.

Why do banks freeze company accounts after a winding-up petition?

Banks may freeze or restrict a company's accounts when they become aware that a winding-up petition has been presented.

This commonly happens following advertisement of the petition in The Gazette, although a bank may become aware of the proceedings by other means.

The bank's concern arises principally from section 127 of the Insolvency Act 1986.

If a winding-up order is subsequently made, payments made from the company's accounts after presentation of the petition may be void unless validated by the court.

Banks may therefore be reluctant to process payments that could subsequently be challenged.

It is important to understand that the presentation of a winding-up petition does not itself mean that every payment is immediately void.

The statutory consequence generally becomes relevant where a winding-up order is subsequently made.

Nevertheless, the potential retrospective effect of section 127 creates a risk which banks may be unwilling to accept.

The result can be that a company which is still trading finds itself unable to operate its bank accounts in the ordinary way.

Can a validation order unfreeze a company's bank account?

Potentially, yes.

Where a bank has restricted an account because of a winding-up petition, a validation order may provide the legal protection needed for the bank to permit specified transactions.

For example, the court may authorise payments required to meet essential business expenditure.

Depending on the circumstances, the order may cover individual transactions or a defined category of payments.

However, a validation order does not necessarily compel a bank to provide banking facilities or override every contractual or regulatory restriction affecting the account.

The bank will need to consider the terms of the order and its own legal obligations.

It is therefore important to identify the bank's concerns and ensure that the proposed order is drafted in a form which addresses the transactions the company needs to undertake.

Where urgent access to funds is required, it may be appropriate to communicate with the bank while the application is being prepared.

What payments can be covered by a validation order?

A validation order may cover a range of transactions, depending upon the company's circumstances and the evidence presented to the court.

These may include:

  • Payment of employees' wages and salaries.

  • Payment of rent and essential premises expenses.

  • Payments to suppliers necessary for continued trading.

  • Utility bills and other essential operating expenditure.

  • Payments required to fulfil existing commercial contracts.

  • Transactions necessary to preserve the value of company assets.

  • Other specified payments or dealings with company property.

The fact that a payment is an ordinary business expense does not automatically mean that it will be validated.

The court will consider why the transaction is necessary and whether permitting it would be consistent with the interests of creditors.

For example, paying a supplier may be justified where the payment enables the company to complete profitable work and preserve value for creditors generally.

The position may be different where the proposed payment would simply benefit one creditor at the expense of others without any corresponding commercial justification.

The nature and purpose of the transaction will therefore be important.

Can a validation order allow the company to continue trading?

Yes, in appropriate circumstances.

A validation order may permit a company to continue making specified payments and undertaking transactions necessary for its business operations.

This can be particularly important where the company is commercially viable but is facing a winding-up petition arising from a particular debt or dispute.

For example, a company may have ongoing contracts, employees and customers, but be unable to meet its trading obligations because its bank account has been restricted.

Where the evidence demonstrates that continued trading is likely to preserve or enhance the value available to creditors, the court may be prepared to authorise appropriate transactions.

However, the court will be concerned to ensure that the company's assets are not improperly depleted.

A validation order should not be regarded as permission to continue trading without regard to the company's financial position or the interests of creditors.

Directors must continue to comply with their legal duties, including those arising where the company is insolvent or approaching insolvency.

What will the court consider when deciding whether to grant a validation order?

The court will examine the circumstances of the company and the transactions for which validation is sought.

A central consideration will be whether the proposed transactions are likely to prejudice the interests of creditors generally.

The court may consider:

  • The company's current financial position.

  • Whether the company is solvent or insolvent.

  • The nature and amount of its assets and liabilities.

  • Its recent trading history.

  • The reasons for the winding-up petition.

  • Whether the petition debt is admitted or disputed.

  • The purpose of the proposed transactions.

  • Whether the payments are necessary to preserve the business or its assets.

  • Whether the transactions are likely to benefit creditors generally.

  • Whether the company can continue trading without increasing the overall deficiency to creditors.

  • The availability and reliability of the financial evidence.

Where a company is solvent and the winding-up petition is disputed, the circumstances may be more favourable than where the company is plainly insolvent and continued trading would place additional assets at risk.

However, solvency is not the only consideration.

The court must assess the particular transactions and their likely effect on the position of creditors.

The leading authority, Re Gray's Inn Construction Co Ltd [1980] 1 WLR 711, establishes important principles concerning the exercise of the court's discretion under section 127.

In broad terms, the court will be concerned with whether the proposed disposition is justified in the interests of the company and its creditors, rather than simply whether the company wishes to make the payment.

What evidence is needed for a validation order?

Applications for validation orders ordinarily require detailed financial evidence.

The court will need sufficient information to understand the company's position and assess the effect of the proposed transactions.

Depending on the circumstances, relevant documents may include:

  • Recent management accounts.

  • The latest annual accounts.

  • Up-to-date bank statements.

  • A schedule of the company's assets and liabilities.

  • Details of secured and unsecured creditors.

  • A current cash-flow forecast.

  • A trading forecast showing anticipated income and expenditure.

  • Details of the payments for which validation is sought.

  • Supporting invoices, contracts or other commercial documents.

  • Evidence concerning the underlying winding-up petition.

  • An explanation of how the proposed transactions will affect creditors.

The application will generally be supported by a witness statement from a director or another person with sufficient knowledge of the company's affairs.

The evidence should explain why the payments are required, the consequences if they cannot be made and why granting the order would be appropriate.

Where continued trading is proposed, the court may require evidence demonstrating that trading can take place without causing further prejudice to creditors.

An unsupported assertion that the company is viable or expects future income will not ordinarily be sufficient.

Can a validation order be obtained urgently?

Yes.

Applications for validation orders can be urgent, particularly where a company has been unable to operate its bank account and faces immediate difficulties paying employees or meeting essential business obligations.

In appropriate circumstances, the court may be asked to consider an application on an expedited basis.

The urgency of the application should be explained in the supporting evidence.

For example, the company may need to demonstrate that employees' wages are due imminently, that a critical supplier requires payment or that an important contract will be lost unless a particular transaction is permitted.

The court will still require a proper evidential basis for granting relief.

Urgency does not remove the need to explain the company's financial position or the effect of the proposed payments.

Where there is insufficient time to prepare a comprehensive application, it may be appropriate to seek limited interim relief for particular essential transactions, with a further application or hearing to follow.

The appropriate procedure will depend on the circumstances and the court's directions.

Can a validation order cover future payments?

Yes.

A validation order does not necessarily have to be limited to a single payment.

In appropriate circumstances, the court may authorise a defined category of future transactions or payments during a specified period.

For example, a company may seek permission to make ordinary trading payments necessary to fulfil existing contracts, subject to limits or other conditions.

The scope of the order must be sufficiently clear.

The court will ordinarily want to understand the anticipated expenditure, the period for which validation is sought and the effect of the transactions on creditors.

A company should not assume that a general request for permission to operate its bank account without restriction will be granted.

The more extensive the proposed validation, the greater the importance of reliable financial information and a convincing commercial justification.

Where appropriate, the order may contain restrictions concerning the nature, amount or timing of permitted payments.

This can provide a practical means of allowing a business to operate while protecting the interests of creditors.

Can payments already made be retrospectively validated?

Yes.

The court has power to validate transactions retrospectively.

This may be relevant where a company has made payments after presentation of a winding-up petition without first obtaining a validation order.

For example, the company may have continued making ordinary business payments before becoming aware of the petition or before appreciating the potential effect of section 127.

If a winding-up order is subsequently made, those transactions may be vulnerable to challenge.

An application may therefore be made seeking retrospective validation.

However, retrospective validation is not automatic.

The court will examine the circumstances in which the payments were made, their purpose and their effect on creditors.

It may be necessary to demonstrate that the transactions were made in good faith and were commercially justified, and that validation would not improperly prejudice creditors.

The evidence required will depend upon the nature of the transactions and the circumstances of the case.

Where substantial payments have already been made, early advice may be important to assess whether retrospective validation should be sought.

Is a validation order always necessary after presentation of a winding-up petition?

No.

The presentation of a winding-up petition does not automatically prohibit every transaction involving company property.

Section 127 is concerned with the consequences of dispositions made after commencement of the winding up where a winding-up order is subsequently made.

If the petition is dismissed without a winding-up order being made, the statutory avoidance consequence under section 127 will not ordinarily arise from that petition.

However, directors and third parties may be unable to predict the outcome of the proceedings.

A bank may therefore be unwilling to process payments without the protection of a court order.

A validation order can provide certainty in relation to specified transactions where there is a real risk that section 127 may become applicable.

Whether an application is necessary will depend on the nature of the proposed payments, the company's circumstances, the position of its bank and the likely course of the winding-up proceedings.

Can the company pay the petitioning creditor without a validation order?

Particular care is required where a company proposes to pay the petitioning creditor after presentation of a winding-up petition.

Although payment may lead to the original creditor agreeing not to pursue the petition, it does not automatically bring the proceedings to an end.

Another creditor may, in appropriate circumstances, seek to continue the petition.

If a winding-up order is subsequently made, payment from company assets after presentation of the petition may be vulnerable under section 127 unless validated.

This can create complications even where the original intention was to resolve the insolvency proceedings.

Depending on the circumstances, it may be appropriate to consider a validation order or arrangements involving funds belonging to a third party.

The source of the payment, the position of other creditors and the proposed procedure for disposing of the petition should be carefully considered.

A company should not assume that paying the petitioning creditor will necessarily eliminate the legal risks associated with the proceedings.

What if the winding-up petition is based on a disputed debt?

Where the petition debt is genuinely disputed on substantial grounds, the company may have grounds to challenge the petition itself.

In those circumstances, an injunction restraining advertisement or an application to dismiss the petition may be more appropriate than relying solely on a validation order.

A winding-up petition should not ordinarily be used to enforce a debt genuinely disputed on substantial grounds.

Where the company has a substantial cross-claim against the creditor, this may also provide grounds for challenging the proceedings.

However, defending the petition and obtaining a validation order are separate matters.

An injunction may prevent the petition from being advertised, while a validation order protects specified transactions against the potential consequences of section 127.

Depending on the circumstances, the company may need to pursue both forms of relief.

At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we can assess the underlying commercial dispute and advise on the appropriate combination of remedies.

Can a validation order be obtained if the company is insolvent?

Potentially, yes, although the application may be more difficult.

The court will be particularly concerned about the effect of proposed transactions where the company is insolvent.

Continued trading may be inappropriate if it would increase the company's liabilities or diminish the assets available to creditors.

However, some transactions may be justified because they preserve the value of the business or prevent a greater loss to creditors.

For example, limited expenditure may be necessary to protect valuable assets or complete a transaction that will produce a net benefit for the company's creditors.

The court will consider the particular circumstances and the evidence supporting the proposed payments.

A validation order should not be treated as a general authorisation to continue trading an insolvent company.

Directors must also consider their duties to creditors and the risks associated with wrongful trading, preferences and other transactions that may be challenged in a subsequent liquidation.

Where the company's financial position is seriously deteriorating, advice from a licensed insolvency practitioner may also be appropriate.

Does a validation order prevent the company from being wound up?

No.

A validation order does not determine whether a winding-up order should be made.

Its purpose is to permit or validate specified transactions notwithstanding the potential application of section 127.

The winding-up petition will ordinarily continue unless it is separately withdrawn, dismissed or otherwise disposed of.

The company may therefore need to take steps to defend the petition, negotiate a settlement or seek an adjournment while the validation order is in place.

For example, a company may obtain a validation order permitting essential payments while simultaneously defending a petition based on a disputed debt.

Alternatively, a company awaiting refinancing may seek validation of necessary transactions while applying for an adjournment to allow time for payment.

The appropriate approach will depend upon the company's financial and legal position.

What happens if a validation order is refused?

If the court refuses a validation order, the company may remain unable to make the transactions for which permission was sought, particularly where its bank is unwilling to process them.

The court may refuse an application because the evidence is insufficient, the proposed transactions are not adequately justified or the company's financial position raises concerns about prejudice to creditors.

Depending on the reasons for refusal, it may be possible to provide further evidence or seek a more limited order.

However, the company should not assume that repeated applications will be appropriate.

It may instead be necessary to consider alternative arrangements, settlement of the petition or other steps to address the company's financial position.

Where the company cannot continue trading without access to its accounts, urgent consideration of the available options may be required.

Should specialist insolvency counsel be instructed?

Applications for validation orders can involve complex issues of insolvency law, financial evidence and the interests of creditors.

It will often be appropriate to obtain advice from specialist insolvency counsel, particularly where the application is urgent, the company is insolvent or the proposed transactions are substantial.

At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we work closely with experienced barristers specialising in insolvency law.

Where appropriate, we can arrange for counsel to advise on the proposed application, assist with the legal arguments and represent the company at court.

This can be particularly valuable where the company requires an urgent order or where the application is likely to be contested.

We can also coordinate the preparation of the necessary financial evidence with the company's directors, accountants and other professional advisers.

How much does a validation order cost?

The costs of obtaining a validation order will depend upon the urgency and complexity of the application.

A relatively limited application concerning specific payments may require less work than an application seeking permission for a company to continue trading over an extended period.

The amount of financial evidence required and whether the application is contested will also affect the costs.

Our work may include:

  • Reviewing the winding-up petition and the company's circumstances.

  • Advising on the application of section 127.

  • Liaising with the company's bank.

  • Identifying the transactions requiring validation.

  • Reviewing financial information and supporting documents.

  • Preparing the application and witness statement evidence.

  • Instructing specialist insolvency counsel.

  • Arranging an urgent hearing where necessary.

  • Reviewing the terms of the court order and assisting with its implementation.

We will provide an estimate of our fees after considering the circumstances.

Court fees and counsel's fees will generally be additional disbursements.

Where the application is contested, there may also be a risk of an adverse costs order.

How Bowman Abraham Solicitors can assist

At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we advise companies and directors facing winding-up petitions and the commercial difficulties arising from insolvency proceedings.

Our experience in commercial litigation and contentious insolvency enables us to consider both the immediate problem of restricted banking facilities and the wider legal position.

We can assist with:

  • Applications for validation orders under section 127 of the Insolvency Act 1986.

  • Urgent applications to permit essential company payments.

  • Applications for retrospective validation of transactions.

  • Liaising with banks concerning restrictions on company accounts.

  • Preparing the financial and witness statement evidence required by the court.

  • Defending winding-up petitions based on disputed debts.

  • Seeking injunctions to prevent advertisement of winding-up petitions.

  • Negotiating settlements with petitioning creditors.

  • Seeking adjournments where payment or refinancing can realistically be arranged.

  • Instructing specialist insolvency counsel where appropriate.

Our objective is to identify a practical legal solution that protects the company's position while addressing the requirements of the insolvency proceedings.

Where there is a proper basis for doing so, a validation order may provide an important means of preserving business operations and avoiding unnecessary commercial damage.

If your company's bank account has been frozen following the presentation of a winding-up petition, it is important to obtain advice promptly.

A validation order may allow essential payments to be made and, in appropriate circumstances, enable the company to continue trading while the petition remains unresolved.

However, the court will require evidence demonstrating why the proposed transactions should be permitted and how they affect the interests of creditors.

Bowman Abraham Solicitors can advise on whether a validation order is appropriate, assist in preparing the necessary application and arrange specialist representation where required.

Michael Abraham — Partner

07813 493391

michael.abraham@bowman-abraham.co.uk

Bowman Abraham Solicitors

020 3732 0424

This article provides general information about the law of England and Wales and does not constitute legal advice on individual circumstances.