← Corporate Insolvency & Winding-Up

Defending a Preference Claim by a Liquidator: Can You Keep Payments Received Before Insolvency?

If you have received a payment from a company which subsequently enters liquidation, you may be surprised to receive a letter from its liquidator demanding that the money be repaid.

This can happen even where the payment was made in settlement of a genuine debt for goods supplied, services provided or money previously lent to the company.

The liquidator may allege that the payment constituted an unlawful preference under section 239 of the Insolvency Act 1986.

However, not every payment made by a company shortly before insolvency is a recoverable preference.

The liquidator must establish the relevant statutory requirements, including that the transaction placed the recipient in a better position in the company's insolvent liquidation and, subject to the statutory presumptions, that the company was influenced by a desire to produce that result.

The circumstances surrounding the payment can therefore be extremely important.

At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we advise businesses, creditors and company directors facing contentious insolvency claims, including disputes concerning payments and transactions entered into before liquidation.

We can examine the liquidator's allegations, review the relevant evidence and advise on the available grounds for defending or resolving a preference claim.

What is a preference under the Insolvency Act 1986?

A preference is a transaction which places a creditor, surety or guarantor in a better position than they would otherwise have occupied in the event of the company's insolvent liquidation.

Section 239 of the Insolvency Act 1986 allows the court to make orders in respect of certain preferences given by a company before insolvency.

The purpose of the legislation is to prevent companies from improperly favouring particular creditors when insolvency is approaching.

For example, a company experiencing serious financial difficulties may repay a substantial debt owed to one creditor shortly before entering liquidation.

The liquidator may investigate whether that payment constituted a preference.

However, the fact that one creditor was paid while others remained unpaid does not automatically establish a recoverable preference.

The statutory conditions must be satisfied.

Can a liquidator recover payments made before liquidation?

Potentially, yes.

A liquidator may seek to recover payments where the requirements of section 239 are met.

However, the liquidator cannot simply demand repayment of every transaction made during the months preceding liquidation.

The claim must be supported by the relevant facts and legal principles.

In particular, it is necessary to examine:

  • Whether the recipient was a creditor, surety or guarantor.

  • Whether the transaction placed that person in a better position in the event of insolvent liquidation.

  • Whether the transaction occurred within the relevant statutory period.

  • Whether the company was insolvent at the relevant time or became insolvent as a consequence of the transaction.

  • Whether the company was influenced by a desire to produce the preferential effect, subject to the applicable statutory presumption.

These requirements can give rise to substantial factual and legal disputes.

A recipient should therefore not assume that the liquidator's demand is necessarily justified.

What must a liquidator prove in a preference claim?

Section 239 establishes a number of requirements.

The liquidator must demonstrate that the company did something, or allowed something to be done, which had the effect of placing a relevant person in a better position in an insolvent liquidation than they would otherwise have occupied.

The transaction must also fall within the relevant statutory period and satisfy the applicable insolvency condition.

Importantly, the court must ordinarily be satisfied that the company was influenced by a desire to produce the preferential effect.

There is a statutory presumption concerning this desire where the preferred person was connected with the company.

The requirements should be considered individually.

A preference claim may fail where an essential element cannot be established.

What does it mean to put a creditor in a better position?

The legislation is concerned with whether the transaction improves the creditor's position in the event of the company's insolvent liquidation.

For example, an unsecured creditor who receives full repayment shortly before liquidation may be better off than if the debt had remained outstanding.

Had the creditor not been paid, they might have received only a small dividend, or nothing, in the liquidation.

A payment may therefore have a preferential effect.

However, the position is not always straightforward.

The legal and commercial circumstances of the transaction must be examined.

For example, where a creditor receives payment in connection with a transaction involving the provision of new goods or services, it may be necessary to consider the overall effect of the arrangements.

Similarly, where the recipient holds security or has other rights affecting its position in the liquidation, the analysis may be different.

The liquidator must identify the relevant transaction and establish the statutory effect.

Is every payment made shortly before insolvency a preference?

No.

This is one of the most important distinctions in preference claims.

Companies experiencing financial difficulties often continue making payments to suppliers, employees, lenders and other creditors.

Some payments may be essential to keeping the business operating.

A company may pay a supplier because it needs further deliveries, wishes to preserve an important commercial relationship or is responding to demands for payment.

The fact that the payment improves the recipient's financial position does not necessarily establish that the company was influenced by a desire to prefer that creditor.

The company's reasons for making the payment may be central to the claim.

Ordinary commercial payments

Payments made in the ordinary course of business are not automatically exempt from section 239.

However, the circumstances in which they were made may provide important evidence concerning the company's motivation.

For example, a company may have paid a supplier because continued supplies were necessary to complete existing contracts and generate revenue.

That may support an argument that the payment was commercially motivated rather than influenced by a desire to place the supplier in a better position on liquidation.

The relevant question is not simply whether the payment was routine, but whether the statutory requirements are established.

What is the desire to prefer?

Section 239(5) requires the court to be satisfied that the company was influenced by a desire to produce the preferential effect, subject to the statutory presumption applicable to connected persons.

This is a particularly important element of preference claims.

The leading authority is Re MC Bacon Ltd [1990] BCLC 324.

The case establishes the distinction between intending to make a payment and being influenced by a desire to improve the recipient's position in an insolvent liquidation.

A company may deliberately pay a creditor without necessarily being influenced by a desire to prefer that creditor.

For example, a company may make a payment because it is under commercial pressure or because it believes the payment is necessary to continue trading.

The liquidator must therefore examine why the company made the payment.

Does the desire to prefer have to be the company's only reason?

No.

The desire to prefer does not have to be the company's sole motivation.

A company may have several reasons for making a payment.

The question is whether the relevant desire was an operative influence upon the decision.

However, the existence of a preferential effect is not itself proof of the required desire.

The distinction between the effect of a transaction and the company's motivation is fundamental.

Can payments made under pressure be challenged?

Potentially, although creditor pressure may provide an important defence.

A company may pay a creditor because that creditor has threatened legal proceedings, withdrawn credit facilities or refused to continue supplying goods.

Such circumstances may indicate that the company was responding to commercial pressure rather than seeking to confer a benefit upon the creditor in a future liquidation.

The principle is illustrated by Re MC Bacon Ltd, where the court considered the company's motivation in granting security to its bank.

However, pressure is not an automatic defence.

The court must examine the actual reasons for the transaction.

A company may have been under pressure while also being influenced by a desire to improve the recipient's position.

What evidence of pressure may be relevant?

Relevant evidence may include:

  • Letters demanding payment.

  • Threats of legal proceedings.

  • Statutory demands.

  • Notices threatening termination of contracts.

  • Correspondence concerning suspension of supplies.

  • Demands for repayment of loans.

  • Negotiations concerning repayment arrangements.

  • Evidence that the company required continued supplies to remain operational.

Contemporaneous correspondence may be particularly valuable.

A recipient who is facing a preference claim should preserve documents showing the circumstances in which payment was requested and made.

Can a supplier be required to repay an invoice paid before liquidation?

Potentially, yes.

A supplier may have provided goods or services to a company and received payment of an outstanding invoice.

If the company subsequently enters liquidation, the liquidator may investigate whether that payment constituted a preference.

However, the supplier may have substantial grounds to defend the claim.

For example, the payment may have been made following repeated demands or because the company required further supplies.

The liquidator must establish the statutory conditions, including the required desire to prefer where no connected-person presumption applies.

The fact that the invoice was genuine and properly due does not, by itself, defeat a preference claim.

Equally, the fact that the invoice was paid shortly before liquidation does not establish one.

The surrounding circumstances are critical.

What is the relevant period for a preference claim?

The Insolvency Act 1986 restricts the period during which transactions can ordinarily be challenged as preferences.

Under section 240, the relevant period depends upon whether the recipient was connected with the company.

For an unconnected person, the relevant period is generally six months ending with the onset of insolvency.

For a connected person, the period is generally two years.

The precise onset of insolvency must be determined in accordance with the statutory provisions.

This is not necessarily the date on which the company ceased trading or the date on which the liquidator was appointed.

Why does the relevant period matter?

If the transaction falls outside the applicable statutory period, a claim under section 239 may not be available.

It is therefore important to identify:

  • The date of the payment or transaction.

  • The date of the relevant insolvency event.

  • Whether the recipient was connected with the company.

  • The applicable statutory period.

A liquidator's calculation should not automatically be accepted without examining these matters.

Different statutory causes of action may have different requirements, so a transaction falling outside the preference period is not necessarily immune from every possible challenge.

Who is a connected person?

The Insolvency Act 1986 contains detailed provisions defining connected persons.

These include certain directors, shadow directors, associates and companies connected through the relevant statutory relationships.

The definitions are found principally in sections 249 and 435 of the Act.

A person may be connected with the company even where the relationship is not immediately obvious.

The statutory definitions must therefore be considered carefully.

Connected-person status is important because it affects both the relevant period and the evidential burden concerning the desire to prefer.

Are payments to directors treated differently?

Yes.

Payments to directors and other connected persons may be more vulnerable to challenge.

Where the preferred person was connected with the company at the relevant time, section 239(6) provides a rebuttable presumption that the company was influenced by the requisite desire to prefer.

This means that the liquidator may not have to prove the desire in the same way as in a claim against an unconnected creditor.

The recipient may need to produce evidence rebutting the presumption.

However, a payment to a director is not automatically recoverable merely because the recipient was connected with the company.

The remaining statutory requirements must still be satisfied.

Repayment of a director's loan

A common example involves a company repaying money previously lent to it by a director.

The loan may have been genuine and properly recorded in the company's accounts.

Nevertheless, where repayment occurs shortly before insolvency, the liquidator may consider whether it constituted a preference.

The director may need to explain the circumstances and reasons for repayment.

It may be relevant to examine whether repayment was required under the loan agreement, whether there were commercial reasons for the payment and what the company's financial position was at the time.

The existence of a genuine loan does not necessarily prevent a preference claim.

However, the statutory requirements must still be established.

What if the director was also a guarantor of company debts?

Preference claims can also arise where a transaction improves the position of a guarantor or surety.

For example, a director may have personally guaranteed a company's borrowing.

The company may subsequently make payments which reduce the director's exposure under the guarantee.

Depending upon the circumstances, the liquidator may investigate whether the transaction had the effect of preferring the guarantor.

The legal analysis may be more complicated than a straightforward repayment to a creditor.

It is necessary to consider the underlying guarantee, the company's obligations and the effect of the transaction.

The director's relationship with the company may also be relevant to the statutory presumption.

Does the company have to be insolvent when the payment is made?

The insolvency condition is an important requirement.

Under section 240, a preference is generally vulnerable only where the company was unable to pay its debts within the meaning of section 123 at the time of the transaction or became unable to pay its debts in consequence of it.

There are statutory provisions affecting the application of this condition to connected persons.

The company's financial position at the relevant time may therefore be a central issue.

How is insolvency established?

The liquidator may rely upon evidence including:

  • Management accounts.

  • Bank statements.

  • Cash-flow forecasts.

  • Outstanding creditor balances.

  • HMRC liabilities.

  • Overdue invoices.

  • Failed payment arrangements.

  • The company's assets and liabilities.

  • Evidence concerning its ability to meet debts as they fell due.

The fact that the company subsequently entered liquidation is not necessarily sufficient to establish that it was insolvent at every earlier date.

The relevant statutory tests must be applied to the evidence.

Is there a presumption of insolvency for connected persons?

Yes.

Section 240 contains a statutory presumption relevant to the insolvency condition where the transaction involves a connected person.

The precise application of the presumption depends upon the statutory requirements.

This can place connected recipients in a more difficult evidential position.

However, the presumption is rebuttable.

Contemporaneous financial records may therefore be important when defending a claim.

Can a preference claim be defended by showing the company was still trading?

The fact that a company was trading may be relevant, but it is not conclusive.

A company can continue trading while being insolvent.

Equally, a company may experience financial difficulties without necessarily satisfying the statutory insolvency condition at a particular date.

The question is whether the relevant legal test is met.

Evidence of ongoing contracts, available funding, expected receipts and the company's ability to meet liabilities may assist.

However, the assessment must be realistic and supported by the financial evidence.

Can a liquidator challenge payments made to a secured creditor?

Potentially.

However, the position may differ from a payment made to an ordinary unsecured creditor.

Where a creditor holds valid security over the company's assets, it may already enjoy priority rights in the liquidation.

The effect of a payment upon that creditor's position must therefore be considered carefully.

For example, repayment of a fully secured debt may not necessarily place the creditor in a better position than it would have occupied in the liquidation.

However, questions may arise where the security is insufficient, where additional security was granted or where the transaction affects the position of a guarantor.

The nature and value of the security may be critical.

Can the liquidator recover the entire payment?

Not necessarily.

The remedy will depend upon the transaction and the court's powers under section 241 of the Insolvency Act 1986.

The court may make such order as it thinks fit for restoring the position to what it would have been if the company had not given the preference.

This may include an order requiring repayment or other appropriate relief.

However, the court's jurisdiction is restorative.

The remedy must be considered by reference to the statutory purpose and the circumstances of the transaction.

A liquidator should not assume that every preference claim automatically entitles the liquidation estate to the full amount demanded without further analysis.

Can the recipient become a creditor again after repayment?

Potentially.

Where a transaction is reversed, the court may make orders addressing the consequences, including the revival of obligations or the treatment of liabilities.

Section 241 contains provisions enabling the court to make appropriate restorative orders.

A recipient who repays a preferential payment may therefore have a claim in the liquidation, depending upon the circumstances.

However, that claim may rank as an unsecured debt and produce only a limited dividend.

The financial consequences of settlement or judgment should be considered carefully.

Can a liquidator demand repayment without going to court?

A liquidator may write to the recipient asserting that a payment constituted a preference and requesting repayment.

The liquidator may also propose a settlement.

However, the liquidator's demand does not itself establish that the recipient is legally liable.

Where liability is disputed and no agreement is reached, the liquidator may need to seek relief from the court.

The recipient is entitled to challenge the factual and legal basis of the claim.

A demand letter should therefore be examined carefully before payment is made or liability is admitted.

What should you do if you receive a preference claim letter?

The first step is to identify precisely what the liquidator alleges.

The letter should be considered alongside the relevant transactions and supporting documentation.

It may be necessary to establish:

  • Which payments are challenged.

  • The dates and amounts involved.

  • The contractual basis for the payments.

  • Whether the recipient was connected with the company.

  • The relevant insolvency date.

  • The company's financial position.

  • The alleged preferential effect.

  • The evidence concerning the company's desire to prefer.

  • The remedy sought by the liquidator.

Where the liquidator has provided only limited information, it may be appropriate to request further particulars or supporting documents.

The recipient should also preserve relevant correspondence and records.

It is important not to make unnecessary admissions before understanding the legal basis of the claim.

What are the main defences to a preference claim?

The available defence will depend upon the facts.

Potential grounds for resisting a claim include the following.

1. The transaction did not have a preferential effect

The recipient may contend that the transaction did not place them in a better position in the company's insolvent liquidation.

This may be particularly relevant where security or other contractual rights affected the recipient's position.

2. The company was not influenced by a desire to prefer

For an unconnected recipient, this may be a central defence.

The company may have made the payment because of commercial pressure, the need to continue trading or other business considerations.

The evidence must establish the company's actual motivation.

3. The transaction falls outside the relevant statutory period

The dates of the transaction and onset of insolvency may demonstrate that the payment falls outside the applicable six-month or two-year period.

4. The statutory insolvency condition is not satisfied

The recipient may dispute whether the company was insolvent at the relevant time or became insolvent because of the transaction.

The applicable statutory presumptions must be considered.

5. The recipient was not a connected person

Where the liquidator relies upon connected-person presumptions, it may be necessary to examine whether the statutory definition is actually satisfied.

6. The liquidator has incorrectly characterised the transaction

The liquidator may have misunderstood the commercial arrangements or failed to consider the transaction as a whole.

For example, a payment may form part of a wider contractual arrangement involving new value or continuing obligations.

The legal effect of the transaction must be analysed carefully.

7. The remedy sought is excessive or inappropriate

Even where a preference is established, the recipient may dispute the form or extent of the relief sought.

The court's powers under section 241 are directed towards restoring the position rather than imposing a punishment.

What evidence is important when defending a preference claim?

Contemporaneous evidence is often central to the defence.

Relevant documents may include:

  • The underlying contract or loan agreement.

  • Invoices and statements of account.

  • Letters demanding payment.

  • Emails concerning overdue debts.

  • Threats of legal proceedings or enforcement.

  • Correspondence concerning continued supplies.

  • Payment arrangements and settlement discussions.

  • Bank statements and payment records.

  • Company management accounts.

  • Cash-flow forecasts.

  • Board minutes.

  • Correspondence with accountants or financial advisers.

  • Documents concerning security or guarantees.

The evidence may help establish why the company made the payment and whether the statutory requirements are satisfied.

Where the recipient was a director or connected person, financial records and evidence explaining the reasons for payment may be particularly important.

Can a preference claim be settled?

Yes.

Preference claims are frequently capable of commercial settlement.

The liquidator may be willing to compromise where there are substantial evidential difficulties, uncertainty concerning the statutory requirements or concerns about the costs of litigation.

The recipient may also wish to avoid the expense and disruption of contested proceedings.

However, settlement should be considered in light of the merits of the claim.

The fact that a liquidator has demanded repayment does not necessarily mean that a substantial payment should be offered.

What should a settlement agreement cover?

Depending upon the circumstances, the settlement may need to address:

  • The agreed payment, if any.

  • The timing of payment.

  • Whether the agreement constitutes full and final settlement.

  • Release from further claims concerning the identified transactions.

  • Interest and legal costs.

  • Existing or threatened proceedings.

  • The treatment of any revived debt or proof in the liquidation.

  • The position of other potentially liable parties.

Where the liquidator has raised several different causes of action, the scope of the settlement should be particularly clear.

For example, settling a preference claim may not automatically resolve a separate allegation of breach of directors' duties unless the agreement addresses it.

What happens if the liquidator issues court proceedings?

Where a preference claim cannot be resolved, the liquidator may apply to the court for relief under section 239.

The court will consider the evidence and determine whether the statutory requirements have been established.

The recipient may defend the application.

The proceedings may involve witness evidence, financial records and detailed examination of the circumstances surrounding the transaction.

In some cases, the central dispute will concern the company's desire to prefer.

In others, the relevant insolvency date, connected-person status or preferential effect may be disputed.

Where the liquidator succeeds, the court may make an appropriate restorative order under section 241.

The court may also make orders concerning the costs of the proceedings.

Contested litigation can therefore involve substantial financial risk.

Is there a limitation period for preference claims?

Limitation requires careful consideration.

A preference application under section 239 is a statutory insolvency claim, and the applicable limitation analysis may differ from that governing an ordinary contractual debt claim.

The relevant limitation period, its commencement and any applicable statutory provisions must be considered in light of the particular proceedings.

The fact that a transaction occurred several years earlier does not, by itself, establish that the claim is time-barred.

Equally, a liquidator does not have an unlimited period in which to pursue every historic transaction.

Where the claim concerns an older payment, limitation should be examined as part of the defence.

Can a preference claim be brought against someone who acted honestly?

Yes.

A preference claim does not necessarily depend upon wrongdoing by the recipient.

A supplier may have acted entirely properly in demanding payment of an outstanding invoice.

The company may nevertheless have made the payment in circumstances which satisfy the statutory requirements.

The legislation focuses principally upon the transaction and the company's conduct and motivation.

The recipient's honesty does not automatically prevent recovery.

However, the circumstances in which the recipient requested and received payment may be important evidence concerning the company's reasons for making it.

This is one reason why preference claims against ordinary commercial creditors can be particularly contentious.

How much does it cost to defend a preference claim?

The legal costs depend upon the amount claimed, the complexity of the transactions and the evidence available.

Some claims may be resolved following a review of the documents and correspondence with the liquidator.

Others may involve substantial financial evidence, witness statements and contested court proceedings.

Our work may include:

  • Reviewing the liquidator's letter of claim.

  • Analysing the statutory requirements.

  • Investigating the relevant transactions.

  • Examining the company's financial position.

  • Advising on connected-person presumptions.

  • Preparing a substantive response.

  • Requesting further information or evidence.

  • Negotiating settlement.

  • Defending court proceedings.

  • Instructing specialist insolvency counsel where appropriate.

At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we can provide an estimate of our fees once we have reviewed the claim and relevant documents.

Court fees and counsel's fees, where applicable, will generally be additional.

We will also explain the potential costs consequences of contested proceedings.

Should specialist insolvency counsel be instructed?

Where a preference claim involves substantial sums or difficult legal issues, specialist counsel may be appropriate.

For example, counsel may assist where the dispute concerns the desire to prefer, the effect of connected-person presumptions or complex financial transactions.

At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we work with experienced barristers in commercial litigation and insolvency matters.

Where appropriate, we can arrange for counsel to advise on the merits of the defence, assist with contested applications and represent the recipient at court.

How Bowman Abraham Solicitors can assist

At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we advise businesses, creditors and directors facing contentious insolvency claims.

We understand that receiving a demand from a liquidator to repay money previously received can be particularly concerning.

The recipient may have supplied goods or services in good faith and reasonably believed that the payment brought the matter to an end.

However, the liquidator must establish the statutory basis for recovery.

We can assist with:

  • Defending preference claims under section 239 of the Insolvency Act 1986.

  • Claims involving payments to suppliers and trade creditors.

  • Claims involving directors and connected persons.

  • Disputes concerning repayment of directors' loans.

  • Challenging allegations concerning the desire to prefer.

  • Investigating insolvency and the relevant statutory periods.

  • Reviewing financial and contractual evidence.

  • Negotiating settlements with liquidators.

  • Defending contested court applications.

  • Arranging specialist insolvency counsel where appropriate.

Our objective is to assess the claim carefully, identify the available defences and seek the most favourable outcome reasonably achievable.

Speak to a solicitor about defending a preference claim

If you have received a letter from a liquidator demanding repayment of money received before a company's insolvency, it is important to obtain legal advice before accepting liability.

Not every payment made before liquidation constitutes a recoverable preference.

The liquidator must establish the statutory requirements, and the circumstances surrounding the transaction may provide substantial grounds for defending the claim.

Bowman Abraham Solicitors can review the allegations, advise on your legal position and assist with defending or resolving the dispute.

Michael Abraham — Partner

07813 493391

michael.abraham@bowman-abraham.co.uk

Bowman Abraham Solicitors

020 3732 0424

This article provides general information about the law of England and Wales and does not constitute legal advice on individual circumstances.