Once a petition is advertised in The Gazette, it becomes publicly accessible and may come to the attention of the company's bank, suppliers, customers and other creditors.
Banks may freeze or restrict the company's accounts, suppliers may withdraw credit facilities and customers may become concerned about the company's financial position.
In some cases, these consequences can seriously disrupt an otherwise viable business before the court has even considered whether a winding-up order should be made.
However, where there are proper legal grounds for challenging a winding-up petition, it may be possible to obtain an urgent injunction preventing the creditor from advertising it.
Where a petition has merely been threatened, it may also be possible to obtain an injunction preventing the creditor from presenting the petition in the first place.
At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we advise companies facing threatened or existing winding-up petitions, including disputes concerning the underlying debt, applications for urgent injunctive relief and defending insolvency proceedings.
Why is the advertisement of a winding-up petition so serious?
A winding-up petition is a formal application asking the court to place a company into compulsory liquidation.
Creditors commonly present petitions on the basis that a company is unable to pay its debts within the meaning of section 123 of the Insolvency Act 1986.
The presentation of a petition does not mean that the company has been wound up. A winding-up order can only be made by the court.
Nevertheless, the existence of the petition can have significant consequences.
The position becomes particularly serious once the petition is advertised.
Advertisement places information about the proceedings into the public domain and may alert parties who would otherwise have been unaware of the petition.
For a trading company, this can create immediate commercial difficulties.
What happens when a winding-up petition is advertised?
The consequences may include:
The company's bank freezing or restricting its accounts.
Suppliers withdrawing credit facilities or requiring payment in advance.
Customers becoming reluctant to enter into new contracts.
Existing commercial relationships being disrupted.
Other creditors seeking to support the winding-up petition.
Difficulties obtaining finance or completing commercial transactions.
Reputational damage arising from the public disclosure of the proceedings.
These consequences may arise even where the company has a legitimate defence to the debt claimed.
This is one reason why the courts recognise that insolvency proceedings should not be used improperly to exert pressure over genuinely disputed debts.
When can a winding-up petition be advertised?
The advertisement of a creditor's winding-up petition is governed principally by rule 7.10 of the Insolvency (England and Wales) Rules 2016.
Unless the court directs otherwise, a creditor's petition must generally be advertised:
Not less than seven business days after the petition has been served on the company.
Not less than seven business days before the date fixed for the petition hearing.
The advertisement ordinarily appears in The Gazette.
The precise timetable will depend on when the petition was presented and served, the hearing date and any directions made by the court.
Importantly, a company should not assume that it has a substantial period in which to respond.
Once the petition has been served, the creditor may be preparing to advertise it as soon as the applicable procedural requirements permit.
Where there are grounds for challenging the petition, urgent action may therefore be necessary.
Can you obtain an injunction to stop a winding-up petition being advertised?
Yes.
Where a winding-up petition has been presented but has not yet been advertised, the company may apply to the court for an injunction restraining advertisement.
Such an application may be appropriate where the petition is based on a debt genuinely disputed on substantial grounds, where the company has a substantial cross-claim or where the petition is otherwise an improper use of the insolvency process.
The purpose of the injunction is to prevent the creditor from publicising the petition while the legal challenge is considered.
The court will examine the grounds relied upon and the evidence supporting the company's position.
An injunction is not automatic simply because the company objects to the petition or believes that advertisement will cause commercial harm.
There must be a proper legal basis for restraining the creditor.
Where the company establishes that the petition is founded on a debt genuinely disputed on substantial grounds, the court may intervene to prevent the insolvency procedure from being used as an inappropriate method of debt collection.
Can an injunction be obtained before the winding-up petition is presented?
Yes.
It is important to distinguish between two situations.
Injunction restraining presentation of a petition
Where a creditor has threatened to present a winding-up petition but has not yet done so, the company may seek an injunction restraining presentation.
This may be appropriate where the creditor is threatening insolvency proceedings over a debt genuinely disputed on substantial grounds or where there is another sufficient basis for preventing the petition.
The advantage of obtaining relief at this stage is that it may prevent the insolvency proceedings from being commenced at all.
This can avoid the complications arising from the presentation of a petition, including the potential consequences for dealings with company assets.
Injunction restraining advertisement of a petition
Where the creditor has already presented the petition, the company may instead seek an injunction restraining advertisement.
The petition will already exist, but the injunction can prevent the creditor from publicising it while the dispute is addressed.
Depending on the circumstances, the company may also seek dismissal of the petition.
The appropriate application will depend upon the procedural stage and the legal grounds available.
What are the grounds for preventing advertisement of a winding-up petition?
The most common grounds involve a genuinely disputed debt, a substantial cross-claim or an abuse of the insolvency process.
1. The debt is genuinely disputed on substantial grounds
A creditor should not ordinarily pursue winding-up proceedings to enforce a debt that is genuinely disputed on substantial grounds.
For example, a company may dispute an invoice because the creditor supplied defective goods, failed to perform contractual obligations, overcharged for services or otherwise breached the agreement between the parties.
The company must demonstrate that there is a genuine dispute with sufficient substance.
A bare assertion that the debt is disputed will not be enough.
However, the company is not ordinarily required to prove conclusively that it will succeed in defending the creditor's claim.
The central question is whether there is a genuine and substantial dispute that should properly be determined through ordinary civil proceedings rather than through the winding-up process.
Where that threshold is met, an injunction restraining presentation or advertisement may be appropriate.
2. The company has a substantial cross-claim
A company may also be able to prevent a winding-up petition where it has a genuine and substantial cross-claim against the creditor.
For example, a company may accept that it owes an amount under a contract but have a substantial claim against the same creditor for losses caused by defective workmanship, delay, misrepresentation or breach of contract.
Where the cross-claim equals or exceeds the petition debt, and is genuine and substantial, this may provide grounds for restraining the petition, subject to the circumstances of the case.
The company will need evidence supporting the cross-claim.
The court will consider whether the claim has a proper factual and legal basis rather than being speculative or raised merely to delay payment.
The distinction between a defence to the debt itself and a separate cross-claim can be important, and each requires careful assessment.
3. The petition amounts to an abuse of process
A winding-up petition is not intended to be a substitute for ordinary debt recovery proceedings.
Where a creditor uses the threat of insolvency proceedings to pressure a company into paying a genuinely disputed debt, the proceedings may amount to an abuse of process.
This is particularly significant because the commercial consequences of a winding-up petition can be severe, even where the amount claimed is relatively modest.
The court may intervene where the insolvency process is being used for an improper purpose.
However, the mere fact that the creditor is seeking payment, or that the petition will cause commercial pressure, does not of itself establish an abuse.
The company must demonstrate a proper legal basis for the challenge.
What evidence is needed to obtain an injunction?
The evidence will depend on the grounds of the application.
Where the company disputes the debt, it will ordinarily be necessary to explain the underlying contractual or commercial relationship and identify the basis upon which liability is challenged.
Relevant evidence may include:
Contracts, purchase orders and terms of business.
Invoices and payment records.
Correspondence concerning the disputed debt.
Complaints about defective goods or services.
Documents demonstrating breaches of contract.
Evidence of losses supporting a cross-claim.
Relevant financial records.
Correspondence threatening the presentation or advertisement of a petition.
The statutory demand, petition and associated documents, where applicable.
The application will generally need to be supported by witness statement evidence exhibiting the relevant documents.
Where an application is urgent, the evidence must be prepared quickly but carefully.
The court will expect the company to explain the factual and legal basis for the injunction, rather than simply assert that the petition is unjustified.
It is also important to consider the history of the dispute.
For example, where a company has consistently challenged invoices before insolvency proceedings were threatened, that correspondence may provide valuable contemporaneous evidence.
Conversely, a dispute raised for the first time after a petition has been presented may require particularly careful explanation.
How quickly can an injunction be obtained?
Applications to restrain advertisement can be extremely urgent.
Where advertisement is imminent, it may be necessary to seek an expedited hearing.
The procedure will depend upon the circumstances, the court's availability and the urgency of the threatened advertisement.
In an appropriate case, an application may be made at very short notice.
However, the court will expect the applicant to explain why urgent relief is necessary and to comply with the applicable procedural requirements.
Where possible, the creditor should be given notice of the application.
Applications without notice may be considered in exceptional circumstances, but they carry additional obligations, including the duty to make full and frank disclosure of material facts.
The court may also consider whether an undertaking as to damages is appropriate.
For these reasons, urgent injunction applications require careful preparation, even where there is very little time available.
Can the creditor be asked not to advertise the petition voluntarily?
Yes.
Before commencing an injunction application, it may be appropriate to write urgently to the creditor or its solicitors explaining the grounds upon which the petition is challenged.
The company may request an undertaking that the petition will not be advertised pending resolution of the dispute or a court hearing.
Where the creditor accepts that there is a genuine issue concerning the debt, it may agree to refrain from advertisement.
However, a creditor is not obliged to provide such an undertaking.
Where the creditor refuses, or advertisement is imminent, it may be necessary to seek an injunction.
It is important that negotiations do not cause the company to miss the opportunity to obtain effective court relief.
Any undertaking should be clear, preferably recorded in writing, and sufficiently comprehensive to protect the company's position.
What happens at the injunction hearing?
At the hearing, the court will consider the evidence and submissions concerning the proposed injunction.
The creditor may argue that the debt is undisputed, that the company's defence lacks substance or that the alleged cross-claim is insufficient.
The company will need to explain why the petition should not be permitted to proceed to advertisement.
Depending on the circumstances, the court may:
Grant an injunction restraining presentation or advertisement.
Grant interim relief pending a further hearing.
Refuse the injunction.
Give directions for further evidence or proceedings.
Make an order concerning the costs of the application.
The court may also consider whether the winding-up petition itself should be dismissed or whether further proceedings are required.
An injunction restraining advertisement does not necessarily dispose of the underlying debt dispute.
The creditor may remain entitled to pursue its claim through ordinary civil proceedings.
Can the court award costs against the petitioning creditor?
Yes.
Where a creditor improperly threatens, presents or pursues a winding-up petition, the court may make an adverse costs order against that creditor.
This may arise where the company successfully obtains an injunction because the debt is genuinely disputed on substantial grounds or the proceedings constitute an abuse of process.
However, costs remain a matter for the court's discretion.
The outcome will depend upon the circumstances, including the conduct of the parties and the result of the application.
Equally, a company that unsuccessfully applies for an injunction may be ordered to pay the creditor's costs.
It is therefore important to obtain a realistic assessment of the merits before commencing contested proceedings.
What if the winding-up petition has already been advertised?
Where the petition has already been advertised, the position becomes more complicated.
An injunction preventing the initial advertisement will no longer provide the same protection because the information has already entered the public domain.
Nevertheless, the company may still have grounds to challenge the petition and seek its dismissal.
Depending on the circumstances, it may also be appropriate to seek orders restraining further publication or other steps in the proceedings.
The company should establish whether the petition has caused difficulties with its bank accounts and whether other creditors have indicated an intention to support the proceedings.
Where the debt is genuinely disputed, the company may still be able to demonstrate that the petition should not proceed.
However, even a successful challenge may not immediately reverse the commercial consequences of advertisement.
This reinforces the importance of acting before publication wherever possible.
Will the company's bank account be frozen if the petition is advertised?
Not necessarily, but there is a significant risk.
Banks may freeze or restrict company accounts when they become aware of a winding-up petition.
The principal legal concern arises from section 127 of the Insolvency Act 1986.
Where a winding-up order is subsequently made, dispositions of the company's property made after the commencement of the winding up are generally void unless the court orders otherwise.
Under section 129, the commencement of a compulsory winding up ordinarily relates back to the presentation of the petition.
Consequently, transactions made after presentation may be vulnerable if the company is subsequently wound up.
The restrictions do not arise merely because the petition has been advertised.
Rather, advertisement may alert the bank to the existence of the petition and the potential consequences of section 127.
Banks may respond by restricting the company's ability to make payments or operate its accounts.
This can cause serious disruption to a trading business.
What is the difference between an injunction and a validation order?
An injunction restraining advertisement and a validation order serve different purposes.
An injunction is designed to prevent the creditor from presenting or advertising a petition where there are proper grounds for doing so.
A validation order, by contrast, addresses the consequences of section 127 of the Insolvency Act 1986.
It may permit or validate specified transactions involving company assets notwithstanding the potential restrictions arising from the presentation of a winding-up petition.
For example, a validation order may be sought to enable the company to make essential trading payments or continue operating its bank account.
The court will ordinarily require detailed evidence concerning the company's financial position, the proposed transactions and the interests of creditors.
A validation order does not itself dismiss the winding-up petition or establish that the debt is disputed.
In some cases, a company may need to consider both forms of relief.
What if the company can pay the debt?
Where the company accepts that the debt is due and has the funds available, settlement may be preferable to contested injunction proceedings.
However, paying the petitioning creditor does not automatically bring the winding-up proceedings to an end.
The company must consider the creditor's legal costs, whether other creditors have become involved and the steps required to dispose of the petition.
Particular care is required where payment is proposed from company assets after presentation of the petition because of the potential application of section 127.
Depending on the circumstances, it may be necessary to consider a validation order or alternative payment arrangements.
A settlement should be documented carefully and should address the procedure for withdrawal or dismissal of the petition.
Where the company cannot pay immediately but expects funds to become available within a reasonable period, it may be appropriate to seek an adjournment of the petition hearing.
The appropriate course will depend on the circumstances and the company's financial position.
Can an injunction protect the company against other creditors?
An injunction restraining a particular creditor from presenting or advertising a petition does not ordinarily prevent other creditors from exercising their own legal rights.
For example, another creditor with an undisputed debt may independently be entitled to commence insolvency proceedings.
Similarly, where a petition has already been advertised, other creditors may seek to support the petition or, in appropriate circumstances, apply to be substituted as petitioner.
It is therefore important to consider the company's wider financial circumstances.
Where the company has multiple overdue debts, defending one creditor's petition may not resolve the underlying financial difficulties.
An injunction can provide important protection against improper proceedings, but it is not a general prohibition against insolvency action by other creditors.
Should specialist insolvency counsel be instructed?
Urgent applications to restrain the presentation or advertisement of winding-up petitions can involve complex issues of insolvency law, commercial litigation and interim remedies.
It will often be appropriate to obtain advice from specialist insolvency counsel, particularly where the underlying debt is disputed, a substantial cross-claim is relied upon or the application is likely to be contested.
At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we work closely with experienced barristers specialising in insolvency law.
Where appropriate, we can arrange for counsel to advise on the merits of the proposed application, assist with the preparation of the legal arguments and represent the company at an urgent hearing.
This enables us to provide a coordinated approach to both the underlying commercial dispute and the insolvency proceedings.
Where the prospects of obtaining an injunction are limited, we can also consider whether negotiation, settlement or another practical resolution may offer a more appropriate course.
How much does it cost to obtain an injunction restraining advertisement?
The costs will depend on the urgency and complexity of the application, the evidence required and whether the creditor contests the proceedings.
Some disputes may be resolved through urgent correspondence, resulting in the creditor providing an undertaking not to advertise.
Other cases may require an immediate court application supported by substantial witness evidence and representation by specialist counsel.
Our work may include:
Reviewing the statutory demand, petition and supporting documents.
Assessing whether the debt is genuinely disputed.
Investigating contractual defences, cross-claims and set-offs.
Preparing urgent correspondence seeking an undertaking.
Drafting the application and supporting evidence.
Instructing specialist insolvency counsel.
Preparing for and attending an urgent injunction hearing.
Negotiating settlement or dismissal of the petition.
We will provide an estimate of our fees after reviewing the circumstances.
Court fees and counsel's fees will generally be additional disbursements.
Where an injunction application is unsuccessful, the company may also face an adverse costs order.
How Bowman Abraham Solicitors can assist
At Bowman Abraham Solicitors, we advise companies and directors facing threatened or existing winding-up petitions.
Our experience in commercial litigation, contractual disputes and contentious insolvency enables us to consider both the underlying dispute and the urgent legal remedies available.
We can assist with:
Challenging threatened winding-up petitions.
Seeking injunctions to restrain presentation or advertisement.
Advising on genuinely disputed debts and substantial cross-claims.
Preparing urgent witness statements and supporting evidence.
Negotiating undertakings with petitioning creditors.
Defending winding-up petitions and seeking dismissal.
Advising on validation orders where company assets or bank accounts are affected.
Negotiating settlements and payment arrangements.
Arranging specialist insolvency counsel for urgent hearings.
Our objective is to identify the most effective means of protecting the company's position and, where there are proper grounds, preventing the serious commercial consequences of an improperly presented winding-up petition.
Urgent legal advice to prevent advertisement of a winding-up petition
If your company has been threatened with a winding-up petition, or a petition has already been presented, it is important to act promptly.
Where the debt is genuinely disputed or the company has a substantial cross-claim, there may be grounds to prevent the creditor from presenting or advertising the petition.
However, the opportunity to obtain effective relief may be limited by the advertisement timetable.
Once a petition has been advertised, the consequences for the company's banking arrangements and commercial relationships can be serious.
Bowman Abraham Solicitors can assess the grounds for challenging the petition, seek urgent undertakings and, where appropriate, arrange an application for an injunction.
Michael Abraham — Partner
michael.abraham@bowman-abraham.co.uk
Bowman Abraham Solicitors
This article provides general information about the law of England and Wales and does not constitute legal advice on individual circumstances.
